In certain situations, someone may be able to file a lawsuit and keep their identity anonymous. In most cases, the lawsuit will be a matter of public record.
It is in the interest of justice, in some situations, to allow an individual who files a lawsuit, called the plaintiff, to file their lawsuit anonymously. When this is allowed, the name of the plaintiff will not be included in any of the court filings.
Instead, the plaintiff will often be listed as plaintiff John Doe or plaintiff Jane Doe, based on whether the plaintiff is male or female. There can also be variations of these names, including John Roe, Jane Roe, or Baby Doe, when the plaintiff is a minor. These terms can also be used when a lawsuit is filed anonymously because the actual identity of the plaintiff is unknown.
Anonymous plaintiffs may want to conceal their identity for numerous reasons, such as accusations of sexual assault or abuse or a whistleblower lawsuit filed against a powerful employer. When the court grants the plaintiff’s request for anonymity, their identity will be withheld.
For more information on filing an anonymous lawsuit in California, it is important to reach out to a California lawyer.
Common Employment Law Scenarios for Anonymous Filing
There are certain common employment law scenarios when a plaintiff may want to remain anonymous, including:
A plaintiff may want to remain anonymous if they have faced sexual harassment or assault in the workplace for many reasons, especially when the employer is high profile or the offender has a powerful position in the business.
An individual may not want to make their experience public because they do not want others to know they were a victim, the circumstances of the incident, and they do not want to be singled out at work.
In a whistleblower case, an employee is typically trying to expose illegal practices being engaged in by their employer. In these cases, they may fear retaliation, such as demotions or termination.
If a California employee has been discriminated against based on a protected class, they may want to remain anonymous because they do not want the general public to know their situation. Examples of these issues may include their HIV status, gender identity, or pregnancy status.
If a plaintiff has a medical condition or a mental health issue that is a central issue in their case and they feel disclosing their situation could cause a stigma, they may want to remain anonymous. Examples may include depression, anxiety, and other conditions that may result in stereotypes and prejudice.
An employee may also be interested in avoiding retaliation from their employer for filing their lawsuit, for example, wrongful termination. If they are wrongfully terminated, however, they may have an additional legal claim against their employer.
A California employment lawyer can help an individual who wants to file an anonymous employment lawsuit and ensure their identity and their rights are protected.
Legal Standards for Filing Anonymously
A plaintiff can file their lawsuit anonymously when their private interests exceed the interests of the public in an open courtroom procedure and the plaintiff will not be adversely prejudiced. When a court is determining whether a plaintiff can file a lawsuit anonymously, it may examine several elements, such as:
- Whether the plaintiff is only attempting to avoid the hassle and exposure of filing a lawsuit or if they are attempting to protect extremely sensitive private information
- Whether revealing the identity of the plaintiff poses a considerable danger of reprisal against the plaintiff or another individual
- The age of the plaintiff
- Whether it is unjust to the other party
The court may also review additional considerations it deems relevant to reaching a conclusion. For more information on whether an individual may be eligible to file anonymously, they should find a workplace attorney and have a legal consultation in California.
Employer Rights and Opposition to Anonymous Lawsuits
An employer, in general, has the right to investigate an anonymous complaint. Although they cannot retaliate against an employee for filing a complaint, it may be challenging for an employer to handle an anonymous lawsuit.
There has to be a balance between the employee’s right to anonymity with the needs of the employer to address potential misconduct in the workplace and to make sure the investigation is fair. An employer needs to investigate anonymous complaints with the same level of scrutiny as one submitted by a named individual.
Employers should have specific policies and procedures for handling complaints that are filed anonymously. This includes how to investigate the claims and how to address the allegations within.
In some situations, an employer may have a neutral third party to conduct the investigation, especially if the allegation contains serious allegations. The employer must also keep the complainant’s identity confidential when possible.
Find My Lawyer Now!
When Defendants Are Anonymous in Employment Cases
A plaintiff is the individual or party who files a lawsuit. Generally, their identity must be disclosed.
A defendant, on the other hand, is forced to appear in court. A defendant’s reputation, both personal and business-related, can be damaged simply because a lawsuit is filed against them. This is one of the unfortunate issues of litigation.
Even when a complaint is found to be unfounded and filed only to harass the defendant, even though there are remedies available, they may not offset the damage caused to the defendant’s reputation. Because of this issue, a court may allow a defendant’s identity to be hidden under certain specific conditions.
Should You File Anonymously?
Whether a plaintiff should file an anonymous employment lawsuit in California will depend on their unique situation, the potential consequences, and the type of lawsuit they are filing. An anonymous filing can provide protections if the situation is sensitive or if there is a risk of retaliation.
However, if a plaintiff files their lawsuit anonymously, they run the risk of not being taken as seriously as a plaintiff who files their lawsuit and provides their name. Examples of reasons that an individual may want to file their employment lawsuit anonymously can include, but are not limited to:
- The risk of being retaliated against, such as losing their job, being ostracized, or other negative employment consequences
- If the case involves sexual abuse issues or whistleblowing when sensitive information is involved
- Filing anonymously can encourage other individuals to come forward with information or issues they may not otherwise want to share
- Being anonymous serves to protect the privacy of the filer
Situations in which filing a lawsuit anonymously may hinder success or the purpose of the claim may include, but are not limited to:
- An anonymous complaint may be seen as less credible, especially when filed but an authority figure or an employer
- It is more difficult to investigate anonymous claims, which may delay action being taken or result in a less thorough resolution
- An anonymous lawsuit may be more difficult to verify, making it difficult to find out if the complaint is genuine or filed simply to harass or be malicious
It is important to be aware that some court rules and laws may require an individual to provide their identity, even in anonymous filings.
Should I Hire an Employment Lawyer?
When you have any questions or concerns about filing an anonymous employment lawsuit in California, it is important to reach out to a California employment lawyer. Your employment lawyer will be able to discuss the pros and cons of filing anonymously and whether you will be allowed to do so.
LegalMatch provides a free and confidential lawyer matching service that you can use to find an employment lawyer in your area who is familiar with filing lawsuits anonymously. Simply submit your employment concern on the website in as little as 15 minutes and you will get responses from California attorneys in your area who are ready to help you resolve your employment issue.
