Pretrial Settlements

Where You Need a Lawyer:

(This may not be the same place you live)

At No Cost! 

 What Is a Pretrial Settlement?

A pretrial settlement is an agreement reached between two parties in a lawsuit before the case goes to trial. This process is also commonly known as an out-of-court settlement. The terms of a pretrial settlement usually involve one party agreeing to a certain form of compensation or action to resolve the dispute, often to avoid the costs and uncertainty of a full trial.

Pretrial settlements can be negotiated at any stage of a lawsuit, even up to the point where a trial is imminent. It is often the result of negotiations between the parties’ attorneys, possibly with the assistance of a mediator.

Does it Cover Legal Fees?

Whether a pretrial settlement covers legal fees largely depends on the terms agreed upon in the settlement. In some cases, part of the settlement might include an agreement for one party to pay the other’s legal fees. This is often the case in situations where one party’s liability is clear, and they are seeking to avoid a potentially more costly court judgment.

However, it’s not always the case. In some instances, each party may agree to bear its own legal costs. Including legal fees in a pretrial settlement depends entirely on the negotiation and agreement of the parties involved.

Is a Mediator Needed?

A mediator is not necessarily required in a pretrial settlement but can be highly beneficial, particularly in more complex or contentious cases. Mediation is a dispute resolution process in which a neutral third party, the mediator, helps the disputing parties to reach a mutually satisfactory resolution. While the mediator does not have the authority to make binding decisions, they can facilitate communication, encourage negotiation, and suggest potential solutions.

Even without a mediator, the parties, usually through their lawyers, can engage in direct negotiation to reach a settlement. However, a mediator can provide an effective means to settle disputes before they reach trial, saving all parties the potential expense and stress of a courtroom battle.

What Are the Benefits of a Pretrial Settlement?

Pretrial settlements offer numerous benefits. Here are some key advantages of settlement before trial:

  • Cost Savings: Legal proceedings can be expensive. There are costs for attorney’s fees, court fees, expert witness fees, and other related costs. By resolving a dispute before trial, parties can save significant amounts of money.
  • Time Savings: Trials can be lengthy and require a significant time investment from all parties involved. By settling a case before it goes to trial, the parties free up their time and avoid the stress and inconvenience of a prolonged legal process.
  • Certainty: Trials are uncertain. There’s always the risk that a judge or jury might rule against you, even if you think your case is strong. A settlement ensures a certain outcome that’s agreeable to both parties.
  • Confidentiality: Unlike trial verdicts, which become part of the public record, settlements can be kept confidential. This can be particularly advantageous for businesses or individuals who wish to avoid the potential public exposure and reputational damage that can come from a trial.
  • Control: In a settlement, the parties have more control over the outcome. They can negotiate terms that best suit their needs rather than having a solution imposed by a judge or jury.
  • Preservation of Relationships: Trials can be contentious and damaging to relationships. Say the parties have a relationship they wish to preserve (for instance, in business disputes or family law cases). In that case, a settlement can be a less adversarial means of resolving the dispute.
  • Finality: Once a settlement agreement is signed, it’s typically final. This can bring a quicker sense of closure compared to a trial, which can be appealed and thus prolong the dispute.

While there are many benefits to pretrial settlements, understand the details of the settlement and consult with a legal professional before accepting an agreement. This ensures your rights are protected, and the settlement is in your best interest.

When Do Pretrial Settlements Occur?

Pretrial settlements can occur in any type of legal dispute, including civil cases such as personal injury claims, contract disputes, employment disputes, and more. However, they are particularly common in certain types of cases.

Automobile Accident Claims

Automobile accident claims cases often involve clear liability, and insurance companies are usually involved. Insurers have a vested interest in settling claims before they go to court to avoid the uncertainty and expense of a trial. A settlement can occur soon after the accident once damages and liability have been established, or it could take place later in the legal process if initial negotiations do not lead to a resolution.

Personal Injury Claims

In addition to automobile accidents, this also includes slip and fall claims, product liability cases, and other incidents where someone was injured due to another party’s negligence. Pretrial settlements are common in these cases because the defendant (or their insurance company) often wants to limit potential damages and avoid negative publicity. Settlements may occur after medical records and other evidence have been collected, and a demand letter has been sent to the defendant.

Medical Malpractice Claims

These cases can be complex, expensive, and drawn out. Due to their complicated nature and the potential for high damages, if the case goes to trial, a pretrial settlement is often sought by both parties.

Employment Disputes

Pretrial settlements are common in employment disputes such as wrongful termination, discrimination, or harassment cases. Employers may prefer to settle these types of disputes to avoid negative publicity and the disruption of a trial.

Business Disputes

Contract disputes, intellectual property issues, and other business-related disagreements can often be settled before trial. A pretrial settlement can preserve business relationships and avoid the costs and uncertainties of litigation.

The timing of these settlements varies widely based on the specifics of each case. They can happen at virtually any point in the legal process before a verdict is reached at trial. However, they often occur after sufficient evidence has been gathered during the discovery phase but before the case goes to court.

How Are Pretrial Settlements Paid Out?

The payment of pretrial settlements typically depends on the terms agreed upon by the parties. The payment can be made in a lump sum or in structured payments over time. A lump sum payment provides the recipient with all of their money at once, which can be useful for paying off medical bills or other immediate expenses.

In some cases, particularly when the settlement amount is substantial, the defendant might prefer or be directed to make structured settlement payments over time. These are often set up through the purchase of an annuity from an insurance company. This way, the plaintiff receives regular payments over a period of years or even for a lifetime.

The insurer often pays the settlement in cases involving insurance, such as auto accidents or personal injury claims. If an individual is paying, they may use their own personal funds or possibly a loan if the settlement amount is significant.

Is This Different From How a Damages Award Is Paid Out?

A damages award determined by a trial verdict is generally paid out as a lump sum rather than a structured settlement. Once the verdict is rendered, the defendant (or typically their insurer) is usually required to pay the full amount of the judgment in a relatively short period. However, in some cases, especially when large amounts are involved, a court may permit a defendant to pay a judgment in installments.

Do I Need a Lawyer for Help With a Pretrial Settlement?

It is highly recommended to have legal representation when negotiating a pretrial settlement. An experienced attorney can evaluate your case, provide legal advice, and negotiate with the opposing party on your behalf. They can also help you understand the long-term impacts of a settlement agreement to ensure your interests are protected.

In cases of personal injury, for example, an attorney can help determine a fair settlement based on the severity of your injury, medical costs, lost wages, future earning capacity, and other factors. Without a lawyer, you may not get the full compensation you deserve.

If you need assistance with a pretrial settlement, consider reaching out to a lawyer through LegalMatch. LegalMatch is a trusted online legal matching service that connects you with prescreened lawyers in your local area.

With LegalMatch, you can find a lawyer who is well-suited to handle your case and assist you through the settlement negotiation process. Simply present your case, and you will be matched with a lawyer who has the right experience for your needs.

Law Library Disclaimer


16 people have successfully posted their cases

Find a Lawyer