How to Change Judges in Criminal and Family Court

Where You Need a Lawyer:

(This may not be the same place you live)

At No Cost! 
Legally Reviewed
Fact-Checked

 What is a Judge’s Role?

Actionable Insights and Helpful Tips

Actionable Insights and Helpful Tips

  1. Consult a family law attorney immediately if you believe your judge is biased or impartial.
  2. Document all instances of perceived judicial misconduct or bias with specific details.
  3. File a motion to change judges early in the proceedings, as it becomes more difficult later.
  4. Be aware of your state’s specific rules for changing judges, including peremptory challenges.
  5. Understand that changing judges generally doesn’t affect the charges in criminal cases.

Judges make decisions on legal disputes between people, organizations, and the government that shape how society interprets its own laws. Most reach the bench after years in practice. The path to becoming a judge isn’t always direct. Professors, mediators, and lawmakers have all traded their usual desks for a gavel. Once appointed or elected, some judges hear cases regarding a particular subject, like those who work in bankruptcy, probate, juvenile, or family court. Others preside over the full sweep of criminal or civil litigation.

The American court system divides its workload between state and federal jurisdictions. A state judge hears cases born of local ordinances or state statutes, such as neighborhood zoning fights, custody disagreements, theft. Federal judges address questions that ripple across state lines or invoke the U.S. Constitution. These two judicial tiers share a comparable structure: trial courts at the base, appellate courts in the middle and a court of last resort at the top.

In criminal court, the judge acts as a referee. The jury, when present, decides guilt or innocence. The judge protects due process, instructs jurors on the law, and determines punishment after a conviction. Civil litigation can change that role. If the two sides waive a jury, the proceeding turns into a bench trial and the judge acts as umpire and scorekeeper, examining testimony, weighing credibility, and issuing a final judgment. Judges supervise both high-profile felony trials and quiet contract disputes while working as protectors of procedure.

In a bench trial the judge is also the “trier of fact.” They review the evidence presented by both sides and determine whether the side with the burden of proof has presented enough relevant facts to have met their burden and “win.”

What Happens if I Want to Change Judges?

You might sometimes want a different judge to oversee your case. This feeling comes up in all types of courts. The question at the heart of these requests is if the assigned judge can stay fair and impartial.

This concern usually comes from different situations. A judge may own stock in a company part of the lawsuit, be related to some witness, or have previously represented one of the parties. These connections, even when they sound harmless, can create doubt during the case.

When you feel uncomfortable with these connections, you have the right to ask for a new judge. The way you make this request changes by location. Federal courts use a standard set of procedures while state courts create their own. Some jurisdictions accept a basic motion. But others need notarized affidavits or a short hearing. Since the paperwork changes between courts, checking local procedure manuals early can improve your chances of success.

The timing of your request can affect its outcome. Courts usually need you to raise objections once you see them. Many people find it challenging to meet this timing requirement.

Judges also follow ethical standards. When they find a conflict in their background they can step aside on their own, a process called recusal. After this happens, the clerk’s office assigns a replacement and the case moves forward without delays. This backup option helps maintain calm in the courtroom because everyone knows there’s a helpful solution if questions about fairness arise.

How Do I Change Judges in a Child Custody Case?

You need reliable proof that the court’s neutrality could be compromised when you question a judge’s role in your child custody dispute. You should get together record-based evidence like orders that contradict the facts, transcripts that show unequal treatment, or any documented connection between the judge and the other parent. Without a strong evidence file, you won’t be able to move forward with the process.

When your evidence file is ready, your lawyer prepares a motion to disqualify. This document tells a story, presents the evidence, and cites the law that lets you make the request. The judge might step down voluntarily after reading your motion. If they don’t, another judge will review the record to choose if a replacement is needed.

Each state has different laws for this process. The first option, a peremptory challenge, lets you remove one assigned judge per case without explaining why. You can do this only early in the case. The second option needs big evidence but remains an option throughout your case.

You should submit the sworn statement with this information once you find out about the issue instead of waiting until after receiving an unfavorable ruling. Courts treat custody disputes with extra care, so a well-supported motion usually receives quick consideration and can help restore fairness before permanent orders are finalized.

Can I Change the Judge if I Don’t Like How They are Handling My Case?

Still convinced a change is necessary? Local laws explain the next steps down to the font size. Your attorney (or you, if representing yourself) needs to file the motion quickly, attach a sworn statement of facts, and send copies to everyone involved. You can expect the court to check the paperwork closely. Claims of unfairness, once raised, affect the whole proceeding. You should include dates, quotes, and transcripts because anything less might come back stamped “denied.”

Changing judges will not affect the charges a defendant is faced with because judges cannot change a charge. The prosecutor decides the charges and controls whether they will offer the defendant a plea bargain.

A judge can be removed. But the system makes you work for it. You should see this as the last choice, not the first.

Do I Need an Attorney?

Only an attorney can start the request for a new judge. The filing, called a motion to recuse or substitute, needs to present concrete reasons as gut feelings won’t cut it. Courts care about these requests because they touch on every litigant’s right to a fair hearing. When you attempt to manage it yourself, it almost always backfires, delays your case, and suggests to the bench that you’re proceeding without professional help.

If you have been charged with a crime it is important that you have an experienced criminal law attorney representing you. LegalMatch can connect you with the right attorney for your situation.

Experienced trial lawyers know the tendencies of the local bench. Years of arraignments and motions teach them which judges allow wide open cross-examination, who enforces strict timelines, and who leans toward harsher sentences. That inside knowledge serves you well when you have to fight criminal charges with possible jail time.

Family court has its own consequences. A custody order can affect a child’s life for years, so parents need counsel that understands each judge’s outlook on shared parenting, relocation, and enforcement. An experienced family law attorney will know if asking for a different judge makes sense or if another strategy will protect your interests faster.

Criminal matters demand attorneys experienced with criminal procedure and custody disputes call for someone experienced in domestic relations. The right lawyer recognizes early when a judge’s tendencies clash with your goals and knows just how and when to ask for a change.

Save Time and Money - Speak With a Lawyer Right Away

  • Buy one 30-minute consultation call or subscribe for unlimited calls
  • Subscription includes access to unlimited consultation calls at a reduced price
  • Receive quick expert feedback or review your DIY legal documents
  • Have peace of mind without a long wait or industry standard retainer
  • Get the right guidance - Schedule a call with a lawyer today!

Law Library Disclaimer

star-badge.png

16 people have successfully posted their cases

Find a Lawyer