Performance Review Law in California

Where You Need a Lawyer:
Columbus, OH 43085
Columbus GRV, OH 45830
Columbus Grove, OH 45830

(This may not be the same place you live)

At No Cost! 

 What Is a Work Performance Review?

A work performance review is a formal process conducted by employers that evaluate an employee’s performance over a certain period of time. They may also be referred to as performance evaluations or appraisals.

During work performance reviews, supervisors may provide feedback to employees about their accomplishments, strengths, weaknesses, and any areas where they may need to improve. An employer may also use a performance review to set goals for an employee and to identify development opportunities.

What Makes Up Work Performance Review?

Usually, a work performance review will be a meeting with an employee and their manager or supervisor, where they discuss the employee’s job performance. During this meeting, the employee’s manager or supervisor can provide feedback regarding their communication skills, teamwork, productivity, work quality, job knowledge, attendance, and punctuality.

A performance review can also include a review of the employee’s job description as well as a review of goals that were previously set, if there were any. The parties can discuss the progress that was made towards the goals as well as set updated or additional goals for the upcoming review period.

How Can I Prepare for a Work Performance Review?

If an individual has an upcoming performance review, they may want to take some time to prepare. During some reviews, they may be asked to do a self-evaluation.

This means that the employee is asked to evaluate their own job performance as well as identify their strengths and any areas they believe they should improve. This may be used to begin discussions during their performance review meeting.

Is a Performance Review the Same as a Grievance?

Performance reviews are not the same as grievances. Grievances are formal complaints that are made by employees regarding alleged unfair treatment or violation of their rights.

The process of filing a grievance will be governed by a business or organization’s policies and procedures that aim to fairly and impartially resolve complaints. An employee can file a grievance related to many different issues, such as:

  • Pay
  • Hours of work
  • Working conditions
  • Job assignments
  • Other workplace issues

Performance reviews, on the other hand, are formal evaluations of the job performance of the employee. These reviews focus on the overall performance of the employee in their job role and do not have to be related to a specific issue or complaint.

Even though performance reviews can be used to identify areas where the employee needs improvement, they are not complaints. If an employee has any questions about California performance review laws and grievances, they can consult with a local attorney.

Can I Sue if My Supervisor Gave Me a Good Review but Fired Me?

If an employee is given a positive work performance review, it does not guarantee that their employment will continue. An employer can usually terminate an employee for any reason or even no reason at all, as long as they have not violated legal protections or anti-discrimination laws when doing so.

If an employee was given a positive work performance review but their employment was terminated based on a protected characteristic, such as age, disability, race, gender, religion, an employee may have grounds to sue their employer for discrimination or wrongful termination.

For more information on whether an employee in California can sue their employer after a positive work performance review, they should consult with a California wrongful termination lawyer.

What Is Performance Evaluation Discrimination?

Performance evaluation discrimination arises when an employee was evaluated unfairly or was given a negative performance review because of a protected characteristic, such as their age, race, or gender.

For example, if an employer regularly provides female employees with lower ratings or more negative reviews than male employees for the same position or provides older workers lower or more negative evaluations because of their age, the employer engaged in performance evaluation discrimination.

An employee’s performance evaluation may have a negative impact on their ability to advance in their career and earn more money. It can also create a hostile work environment, which is illegal under both state and federal laws.

If an employee experiences this type of discrimination, they may be able to take legal action against the employer. In order to prove discrimination occurred, the employee has to show that they were treated differently than other similarly situated employees who were not in the protected class.

If an employee’s positive performance review was followed by their termination, the employee will have to show that other employees who were given similar reviews were not terminated and that they were terminated because of a protected characteristic.

For an evaluation on whether an employee faced performance evaluation discrimination in California, an employee should have a legal consultation in California.

Can My Former Employer Mention My Bad References During a Reference Check?

An employer does have the right to provide factual and truthful information regarding a former employee’s work performance when they are giving a reference check to a potential employer. The employer, however, is not allowed to make subjective comments or to give them misleading information.

If an individual’s former employer provides a bad reference during a reference check and that information is not accurate or not true, the employee may be able to sue for wrongful termination or defamation.

They should make sure to keep any records of their employment, such as performance evaluations and any disciplinary actions against them in order to dispute the negative information the former employer provided.

Can I Sue My Employer for a Bad Review?

In general, an employee cannot sue their employer for a bad performance review unless that review was based on discriminatory reasons or false statements. A negative or bad review may include criticisms of the employee’s job performance.

While a negative performance review may impact an employee’s potential for career growth, it will not necessarily be the grounds for a lawsuit. If, however, that negative review is based on a discriminatory reason, such as the employee’s gender, disability, or age, they may be able to sue for discrimination.

If the negative review includes defamatory remarks or false statements that harm the employee’s reputation, they may be able to sue for defamation. A false statement may include statements that are untrue or misleading.

If an employee believes they have been subjected to a discriminatory or unfair performance review in California, they should consult with a California lawyer for more information on their rights and options for recourse.

An employee can also submit their concerns to their employer’s Human Resources (HR) department or submit a complaint with a government agency, such as the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC).

Should I Hire an Employment Lawyer in California?

If you believe you have received an improper performance review in California or have been wrongfully terminated from your California job, you should consult with a California wrongful termination lawyer as soon as possible. Your attorney will be able to review the facts of your case, obtain evidence to support your claim, and assist you with pursuing legal action if necessary.

If your employer has violated state or federal employment laws, you may be able to receive compensation for your lost wages, emotional distress, as well as other damages. Your wrongful termination lawyer will provide you with guidance no matter which process you follow for resolution and ensure your rights are protected until your issue is resolved.

You can use LegalMatch’s no cost attorney matching services in as little as 15 minutes to find a California employment lawyer who can help you resolve your employment issue. Take advantage of LegalMatch’s services to find legal help today!

Did you find this article helpful?
Not helpfulVery helpful

Save Time and Money - Speak With a Lawyer Right Away

  • Buy one 30-minute consultation call or subscribe for unlimited calls
  • Subscription includes access to unlimited consultation calls at a reduced price
  • Receive quick expert feedback or review your DIY legal documents
  • Have peace of mind without a long wait or industry standard retainer
  • Get the right guidance - Schedule a call with a lawyer today!

Need a Wrongful Termination Lawyer in your Area?

By City/County in California

Show More
Legally Reviewed
Fact-Checked

Law Library Disclaimer

star-badge.png

16 people have successfully posted their cases

Find a Lawyer