Civil Commitment Law

Where You Need a Lawyer:

(This may not be the same place you live)

At No Cost! 

 What is Civil Commitment?

Civil commitment is the term for a court-ordered compelled admission into a rehab center.

Protecting a patient from themselves and the wider public is the aim of civil commitment. Each state has its own statutes that specify civil commitment processes to prevent violating a patient’s due process rights because a patient of a civil commitment is deprived of their personal liberty.

Generally speaking, mental illness, developmental disabilities, and drug addiction are the three conditions that would make a person eligible for involuntary civil commitment under current laws.

In the case of mental illness, the normal commitment requirement is defined as being harmful to oneself or others. Almost all states consider this standard to include the inability to meet one’s fundamental needs as being hazardous to oneself. In terms of procedure, every state guarantees a hearing, the right to counsel, and recurrent judicial review. Most of them have quality standards for medical care and hospital environments governed by statute.

A person who misuses or abuses alcohol or drugs to the extent that they cannot make rational decisions about their basic requirements, such as food, shelter, and medical treatment, would serve as an example.

There is a chance that some persons who are suffering from mental illness could harm themselves or others.

Who Can Be Civilly Committed?

According to legislation, those who qualify for civil commitment must be either physically or psychologically sick, physically or mentally incapacitated, drug addicts, or sexually aggressive predators.

Several states have used civil commitment for sex offenders to permanently banish chronic sexual offenders from society. After a sex offender has completed their prison term and has not broken any other offenses, they may be subject to civil commitment.

This type of involuntary detention is based on the possibility that an individual will commit crimes in the future rather than as a punishment for past actions. Civil commitment has been used for those who represent a serious threat to themselves or others, including those with mental illness, developmental disabilities, or chemical dependence. It is not just reserved for sex offenders.

The U.S. Attorney General or any authorized representative of the Department of Justice or Bureau of Prisons may begin the civil commitment procedure. This is done by designating a person as a “sexually dangerous person” under the provisions of the Adam Walsh Act, a law that was passed in 2006 and governs civil commitment by the federal government.

This can occur with criminal defendants who have been declared incapable of standing trial or with prisoners who are scheduled for release. Federal prisoners who have a history of sexual assault or child molestation often go through a process to identify release risks that could result in the start of a civil commitment.

How Do Civil Commitments Work?

Although the civil commitment statutes vary from state to state, they generally follow the same pattern:

  • An individual commits a crime or is in some other way brought before a court, and their health becomes problematic,
  • A county attorney is given the case’s facts, the county attorney arranges for a pre-commitment evaluation by a specialist, such as a psychologist, the court hears arguments on both sides of the civil commitment issue, and in the end, the court decides to use civil commitment to force the person into a treatment facility.

The majority of states also permit the temporary or urgent imprisonment of someone who is thought to be a candidate for civil commitment. Typically, the permitted period is limited to 24 or 48 hours.

In most jurisdictions, involuntary commitment is used for people who are thought to be suffering from a mental illness that significantly impairs their ability to reason to the point where authorities, the state, or the courts decide that making decisions for them will be necessary under a legal framework. This is a separate proceeding from being determined to be incompetent in some jurisdictions.

Although different jurisdictions have varying standards, each of the following situations involves some degree of involuntary commitment. Some jurisdictions only permit involuntary treatment for those who meet the legal requirements for posing a risk to oneself or others. Broader standards apply in other jurisdictions. There are regional differences in the legal procedure for commitment.

The subject of the hearing is normally entitled to legal representation and may challenge a commitment order through habeas corpus in some countries. These formal court hearings may also allow for testimony and other types of evidence to be presented.

In order to give community people with authority to handle circumstances where involuntary evaluations of behavior are appropriate under the law. These include teachers, school administrators, police officers, and medical professionals, training in mental health first aid is gradually becoming offered.

What Is the Difference between Civil Commitment and Criminal Punishment?

Although civil commitments may resemble criminal penalties, there are three key differences between them:

  • Civil commitment is not intended to penalize a patient for committing a crime but to heal and rehabilitate them.
  • Criminal penalties often have a specific time limit, but civil commitments are typically for an indeterminate period of time, and
  • In contrast to criminal punishment, which typically only requires a preponderance of the evidence, arguing against civil commitment requires clear and convincing evidence to the contrary.

One of the first punishments that come to mind when someone mentions “criminal punishment” is incarceration. By making offenders serve time in jail, society’s law-abiding members are cut off from them. The severity of the offense, whether the offender is eligible for credit for time served while awaiting sentencing, and whether they have a past criminal history are some of the variables that affect how long the prison sentence will be.

The length of a person’s prison sentence can be determined in a sophisticated manner. An accomplished criminal defense lawyer can inform you of your rights and represent you in court if you are facing jail time.

A number of the other criminal penalties listed below, such as fines, parole, and community service, can be combined with jail in certain instances.

While parole and probation may sound alike, they are two distinct forms of punishment. Both punishments offer options to escape jail time and are dependent on an individual’s behavior (i.e., if you act appropriately, you’re fine; if not, you’ll go to jail). Both of these punishments typically consist of what is known as a supervised or conditioned release. The offender will need to continue to meet with a supervising officer regularly, among other eligibility requirements.

But the route you take to get there is where they diverge. A court may include probation as part of your sentence when determining your penalty. The perpetrator is released back into the community rather than being sent to jail. Still, they are required to abide by a rigid set of conditions designed to prevent them from committing another crime.

On the other hand, a parole board decides whether to give you parole after you have completed some (perhaps significant) jail term. (Sometimes, parole is referred to as “getting out on good conduct” in certain settings.)

The state (the government body that prosecuted the crime, whether it was your local county or the federal government) may order fines for less serious violations, such as small drug possession or shoplifting charges. The amount of the fee can vary greatly depending on the offense that was committed.

Do I Need an Attorney for a Civil Commitment?

It is strongly advised that you speak with a criminal defense attorney if you or someone you know is currently involved in or will soon be involved in a civil commitment action because of the serious repercussions that could result. The problems can only be completely explained and your defense supported by an attorney.


16 people have successfully posted their cases

Find a Lawyer