A property dispute in New York involves disagreements related to real estate, often arising from issues such as boundary lines, ownership rights, easements, or property use. Property disputes most commonly occur between neighbors, landlords and tenants, or co-owners, and typically involve matters like fence placement, encroachments, shared driveways, or claims of long-term use.
New York law provides several legal avenues for resolving such disputes. For example, N.Y. Town Law Section 300 addresses boundary fences, requiring adjoining landowners in certain towns to share maintenance responsibilities unless otherwise agreed or exempted.
When disputes involve encroachments or nuisances, such as overhanging trees or obstructive structures, property owners may seek relief under New York Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law (“RPAPL”) or New York Real Property Actions Law Section 861. That law outlines specific damages allowed in such cases, such as allowing for triple damages in cases of intentional tree damage.
In cases where someone has occupied and maintained property openly and without the owner’s objection, they may pursue an adverse possession claim under RPAPL Sections 501 through 551.
In order to succeed on such claims, the claimant must show continuous, exclusive, and hostile use of the property for at least 10 years and, in some cases, demonstrate that they paid property taxes on the disputed land.
Because these disputes often involve complex legal and factual issues, including historical deeds, surveys, and local ordinances, consulting a New York lawyer is the most effective way to protect your rights and work toward a resolution.
Who Can Be Involved in a Property Dispute?
As mentioned above, property disputes in New York can involve a variety of parties depending on the nature of the conflict. Neighbor disputes are especially common and often center around a boundary dispute, fence placement, or easement rights.
For instance, if a neighbor constructs a fence that encroaches onto your land, you may need to pursue a quiet title action or an ejectment proceeding under the Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law to resolve ownership or usage rights.
Landlord-tenant disputes are also frequent and may involve issues such as lease violations, failure to make repairs, or claims of uninhabitable living conditions. These types of disputes are typically handled in Housing Court under the procedures outlined in RPAPL Article 7, which governs summary proceedings for possession.
Disagreements between co-owners, such as family members who inherit property are also common. These disagreements may lead to partition actions under RPAPL Article 9, which allows the court to divide or sell the property and distribute proceeds according to ownership shares. Similarly, buyers and sellers may clash over contract terms, title defects, or disclosure obligations, which can result in litigation for breach of contract or rescission.
Homeowners’ Associations (“HOAs”) also play a role in New York property disputes, particularly in condominiums or planned communities. Common HOA problems arise from HOAs enforcement of bylaws and covenants related to property use, renovations, or assessments. Disputes with homeowners can escalate to litigation if not resolved through internal grievance procedures. Additionally, zoning and permitting issues may involve local municipalities, especially when construction or land use violates local ordinances or requires variances.
What Are Some Common Types of Property Disputes in New York?
As mentioned above, In New York, property disputes frequently arise from disagreements over ownership rights, boundary lines, or land use. One of the most common issues involves boundary disputes, where neighbors contest the precise location of a property line.
These conflicts often stem from ambiguous deeds, outdated or conflicting surveys, or encroachments such as fences, sheds, or driveways. When informal resolution fails, parties may need to commission a licensed surveyor and pursue legal remedies under the Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law.
In cases involving shared fences, New York Town Law Section 300 may apply in certain towns, requiring adjoining landowners to share responsibility for boundary fences. This is particularly true in rural areas or where livestock is involved. Local ordinances and zoning codes may also regulate fence placement and maintenance.
Easement disputes are another frequent source of conflict. These arise when one party claims the right to use part of another’s land for access, utilities, or drainage. New York recognizes both express easements (i.e., written agreements) and implied easements (i.e., agreements arising from longstanding use or necessity). Disputes over the existence, scope, or misuse of an easement may require court intervention to clarify or enforce rights.
Adverse possession is also a legal avenue through which someone may claim ownership of land they’ve used openly, exclusively, and continuously for at least 10 years. In some cases, the claimant must also show that they paid property taxes on the disputed land.
Other common property disputes in New York include foreclosure proceedings, title defects that cloud ownership, eminent domain law actions initiated by government entities, and landlord-tenant conflicts, which are governed by RPAPL Article 7.
Find My Lawyer Now!
What Is a “Cloud” on Title?
In New York, a “cloud” on title refers to any claim, lien, or encumbrance that casts doubt on the legal ownership of a property, making the title appear uncertain or defective. This can affect the title marketability of the property. Common examples of a cloud on title include fraudulent deeds, unreleased mortgages, or recording errors.
In order to resolve such issues, a property owner may file a quiet title lawsuit under Article 15 of the Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law Section 1501. This legal process seeks to remove the cloud and establish the property owner’s clear ownership rights.
What Remedies Are Available for Property Disputes?
In New York, the law offers a variety of different remedies depending on the nature of your particular property dispute. The following is a list of common legal remedies that are available for property disputes:
- Quiet Title Action: Under RPAPL § 1501, a quiet title action allows a property owner to resolve disputes over ownership or remove a “cloud” on the title, such as a fraudulent deed, unresolved lien, or boundary uncertainty
- Ejectment Action: If someone is unlawfully occupying your property and there’s no landlord-tenant relationship, then you can file an ejectment action where you prove superior title
- If successful, the court may order the occupant removed and award damages for lost use or rental value
- Partition Action: When co-owners of real estate disagree on how to use or dispose of the property, a property partition dispute action under RPAPL Article 9 can be filed
- The court may then physically divide the property or, if that’s impractical, order a sale and distribute the proceeds based on ownership shares
- Adverse Possession: A person who has occupied land openly, exclusively, and continuously for at least 10 years may claim ownership through adverse possession, as outlined in RPAPL Sections 501 through 551
- Trespass and Nuisance Claims: If someone interferes with your property rights, such as by building on your land or creating a harmful condition, then you may bring a trespass or nuisance claim
- Injunctive Relief: Courts may issue injunctions in order to stop ongoing or imminent harm, such as preventing a neighbor from continuing construction that encroaches on your land or misusing an easement
- This remedy is especially useful when monetary damages are insufficient to address the issue
- Monetary Damages: In addition to or instead of injunctive relief, courts may award compensatory damages for financial losses, such as diminished property value, repair costs, or lost rental income
In more extreme cases, punitive damages may be available if the other party’s conduct was willful or malicious
Do I Need an Attorney if I Have a Property Dispute?
If you’re facing a legal issue involving a property dispute in New York, it is recommended to schedule a consultation with a New York real estate lawyer who is familiar with local laws and court procedures. LegalMatch can assist you with locating an attorney near you and set up a legal consultation in New York.
These attorneys can help you understand your rights under statutes such as the Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law, and also help you navigate issues like boundary conflicts, easements, adverse possession, or title defects.
As can be seen, property disputes in New York often involve complex legal principles, overlapping ownership claims, and municipal regulations that vary by locality. Working with a qualified attorney ensures that you receive tailored legal advice, avoid procedural missteps, and pursue the most effective strategy for resolving your dispute. This may be through negotiation, litigation, or filing civil actions such as a lawsuit, a quiet title action, or partition. Finally, an experienced lawyer can also represent you in court, as needed.
