Escrow Agent’s Default Liability

Where You Need a Lawyer:

(This may not be the same place you live)

At No Cost! 

 What is Escrow?

Escrow is an arrangement with third parties who are uninvolved in the purchasing and selling of a home. In other words, the third party is not the buyer or the seller.

In a real estate transaction, escrow holds all of the funds which are associated with the transfer of the title as well as maintains all documents and contracts.

What is an Escrow Agreement?

Escrow is a transaction where one individual transfers title to property to another individual to be held in trust for a specific period of time. The individual who is holding the property will then deliver that property to another party after the specified period of time or when a specific event occurs.

The transaction is executed according to the escrow agreement. An escrow agreement is a document, similar to a contract, which states the terms and conditions for the exchange.

The individual who is transferring the property is known as the grantor, or depositor. The party who holds the property is called the escrow agent, or depositary.

The party who receives the property from the agent is called the grantee. An escrow agreement is most commonly associated with the transfer of real estate.

The property in escrow is referred to as escrow property. It is held in escrow during the time which the depositary holds it.

Why is Escrow Important?

Escrow is very important in real estate transactions because it provides assurance that a neutral third party will handle the documents and finances associated with the transaction. In this regard, it makes the transaction safer because it ensures that both the buyer and the seller meet their obligations.

Using escrow also ensures that funds are not exchanged personally between a buyer and a seller. This ensures that if one party fails to perform its obligations, the other party will not automatically receive the funds.

Who are the Parties Involved in Escrow?

Typically, there are three parties that are involved in escrow in real estate transactions, including:

  • The buyer;
  • The seller; and
  • The escrow agent, or third party.

A buyer, also called a promisor in the context of a contract, is the party who agrees to purchase the real estate in the real estate contract. In exchange for the sum that was agreed upon, called the purchase price, the seller agrees to transfer title to the buyer.

The buyer will have a specific amount of time to perform their end of the bargain per the terms of the contract. The amount of time will vary by contract.

A seller, also known as a promise, is the individual who has title to the real estate and sells the property to the buyer. Similar to the buyer, the seller will have a specific amount of time to perform their end of the bargain according to the terms of the contract.

The neutral third party is, in many cases, the escrow agent. It is important to note that, in some states, attorneys are used instead of escrow agents.

The escrow agent’s job is to hold the documents and funds which are part of the transaction in escrow until both parties perform their obligations under the contract. Once both parties complete their duties, the escrow agent will coordinate closing.

On occasion, an escrow agent may default on their duties to deliver a legal document or property which is placed with them in escrow. Examples of defaults which may occur include:

  • Failing or refusing to deliver the instrument or property entrusted to them after the conditions upon which they were to deliver it have been satisfied;
  • Delivering the item to the buyer or seller prior to the specified conditions having been satisfied;
  • Losing the instrument or property entrusted to them; and
  • Embezzling the instrument or property entrusted to them.

Who May be Held Liable in a Breach of an Escrow Agreement?

In most escrow cases, the depositary incurs the liability for a breach, often due to their own misconduct. Depositaries holding property in escrow for the parties owe a duty of care to the grantors and grantees.

If the depositary fails to abide by the terms of the escrow agreements, it may result in a lawsuit. A depositary must abide by the following duties:

  • The duty to follow the instructions which are provided in the escrow agreement;
  • The duty to use good faith and exercise reasonable skill when handling the property; and
  • The duty to deliver the property title at a specified time or when the conditions for transfer are completed.

For example, if an escrow agent’s default causes property to be transferred before the specified time, the agent may be held liable under a breach of contract law. Another common example of breach which occurs is when an escrow agent completely fails to deliver the title and attempts to sell it to a different party.

It is important to note that both a grantor and a grantee can also be held liable for a breach of an escrow agreement. For example, if a grantor illegally tampers with the property prior to handing it over to an escrow agent, they may have breached some terms in the agreement.

A grantee may also be liable for a breach if they wrongfully coerce the agent to hand over the title too soon.

Who Bears the Loss Resulting from an Escrow Agent’s Default?

Between a buyer and a seller, the loss typically falls on the party who owns the property at the time a default occurs. If an escrow agent defaults on their duty prior to the time the seller is entitled to it, the loss then falls on the buyer because it is still the buyer’s money.

If a default occurs after the time at which the seller becomes entitled to the money, the loss would fall on the buyer because it would be considered their property.

What Actions Can I Take Against an Escrow Agent in Default?

If an individual bears the loss which results from an escrow agent’s default, they may have several options available, depending on the state in which they live. There may be several causes of action on which to file a lawsuit, including:

  • Specific performance because some states will force an escrow agent to deliver the instrument placed in escrow after the performance of the specified conditions;
  • Damages, which includes the lost benefit of a sale of the property and any other resulting damages; and
  • Conversion, which occurs when an escrow agent possesses an instrument in escrow for an unreasonable time after escrow has expired, their refusal to deliver may amount to a conversion, making them liable for damages. Conversion means taking an item out of the possession of another with the intention of keeping it despite the original owner’s right to use or possess that item.

How Can I Protect Myself Against an Escrow Agent’s Default?

The best way for an individual to protect themselves against an escrow agent’s default is to ensure that they select an escrow agent they can trust. In addition, an individual can regularly check on the status of escrow as well as ensure that the escrow agent is performing their duties.

Do I Need an Attorney if My Escrow Agent Defaults?

Yes, it is essential to have the assistance of a real estate attorney if your escrow agent defaults and you are liable for the loss. Your attorney can review your case, determine what causes of action may be available to you, and assist you in obtaining specific performance and damages.

In some cases, you may want to report the actions of the escrow agent to law enforcement for possible criminal prosecution.

Save Time and Money - Speak With a Lawyer Right Away

  • Buy one 30-minute consultation call or subscribe for unlimited calls
  • Subscription includes access to unlimited consultation calls at a reduced price
  • Receive quick expert feedback or review your DIY legal documents
  • Have peace of mind without a long wait or industry standard retainer
  • Get the right guidance - Schedule a call with a lawyer today!
star-badge.png

16 people have successfully posted their cases

Find a Lawyer