Top 5 Types of Documents/Evidence to Gather for Your Purchase and Sale of Residence Case

Where You Need a Lawyer:

(This may not be the same place you live)

At No Cost! 

 Types of Evidence (Documents) Required In Court for a Purchase and Sale of Residence Case

The intricacies of real estate transactions, especially those involving the purchase and sale of a residence, require specific documentary evidence to validate claims and ensure smooth proceedings in court. These documents not only help to establish the factual basis of the transaction but also serve as vital tools in legal proceedings, especially in cases of disputes.

Let’s examine the primary types of evidence you might need in such situations.

  • Purchase Agreement: This is the primary document that outlines the terms and conditions under which the property was sold or purchased. It provides prima facie evidence of the agreement’s existence.
  • Title Deeds or Certificate of Title: Serving as the evidence of title in real estate, this document proves ownership of the property. In essence, the title to real estate stands as the main evidence of ownership.
  • Escrow Documents: These confirm the secure handling of funds and other assets until the transaction conditions are met.
  • Property Inspection Reports: Often obtained prior to finalizing the sale, these provide a detailed account of the property’s condition and can help identify any potential undisclosed issues.
  • Communications between Parties: Emails, texts, or letters exchanged between the buyer and seller might be important, especially if there are any oral agreements that could be subject to the parol evidence rule in real estate. This rule ensures that any written contract is the final and complete agreement, barring oral or written statements outside of the contract itself.

How Will This Evidence Make My Purchase and Sale of Residence Case Stronger?

Each piece of evidence serves a unique role in painting a picture of the transaction and any potential discrepancies:

Purchase Agreement

The purchase agreement is essentially the blueprint of the real estate transaction. It outlines the terms, conditions, price, and obligations that both the buyer and seller have consented to. This agreement serves not just as a contract but as the primary reference point should disputes arise.

For instance, if disagreements emerge regarding the amenities included with the property, the fixtures to remain, or the closing date, the purchase agreement becomes the prima facie evidence—the foremost proof of what was initially settled upon. Without this agreement, either party could assert different versions of what was discussed, leading to potential legal gridlocks.

Title Deeds

In the realm of real estate, the Title Deeds or Certificate of Title are equivalent to a badge of ownership. They trace the lineage of ownership, pinpointing every historical transaction involving the property.

When questions arise about the property’s rightful owner or if there are disputes over boundary issues or easements, the Title Deeds step in as undeniable evidence. They are more than just a historical record; they establish legitimacy and provide assurance against potential ownership challenges.

Escrow Documents

Real estate transactions typically involve significant sums of money, often held in escrow until specific conditions are met. Escrow documents act as guardians of this process. They detail how the funds are held, the conditions under which they’ll be released, and the obligations of each party during this phase.

If a seller claims they never received the payment or a buyer alleges they’ve deposited more than what’s acknowledged, these documents serve as the neutral arbitrators, offering a clear, unbiased account of the financial transactions.

Property Inspection Reports

A residence’s allure often lies beneath its surface. Property inspection reports dig deep, unearthing the property’s health, be it structural integrity, plumbing efficiency, or electrical safety.

When a buyer claims they were misled about the property’s condition or alleges the discovery of undisclosed defects post-purchase, these reports become pivotal. They provide a timestamped snapshot of the property’s condition at the time of the inspection, helping to validate or refute any assertions made by either party.

Communications Between Parties

While formal contracts like the purchase agreement lay the foundation, informal communications—be they emails, texts, or letters—add layers of context to a transaction. They capture the nuances, the back-and-forths, the concessions, and the assurances.

Especially important are instances where oral agreements come into play, with the parol evidence rule ensuring that any subsequent oral agreement doesn’t contradict the written contract. These communications offer a window into the intentions and understandings of both parties, helping to dissolve ambiguities and clarify contentious points.

Each of these documents, with their unique strengths, collectively ensures that a real estate transaction is transparent, fair, and legally sound.

How to File Evidence in Court for a Purchase and Sale of Residence Case

Navigating the labyrinth of evidentiary matters is challenging and intricate. These complexities are why it’s best to consult and hire an attorney who handles real estate transactions. With an attorney’s assistance, the maze becomes manageable—they know precisely which documents are relevant, how to present them, and how they can be leveraged to your advantage.

Without legal guidance, there’s a significant risk of overlooking evidence or failing to present it correctly.

What If This Is Not Accepted by the Courts as Evidence?

Should the court reject specific pieces of evidence, all isn’t lost:

Reexamine and Resubmit

The process of reexamination is much like refining a strategy. When evidence is initially dismissed or not accepted, it’s imperative first to understand the reasons behind the decision. This often means ensuring two primary criteria are met: relevance and authentication.

Relevance pertains to how directly the evidence connects to the matter in dispute. Does it shed light on a specific point or claim? Does it provide clarity to a particular event or agreement?

If the relevance is undeniable, then the focus shifts to authentication. This ensures that the evidence, be it a document or an item, is genuine and hasn’t been tampered with. This might involve a closer scrutiny of the evidence, possibly accompanied by expert testimonies or corroborative documents.

Once fortified, the evidence can be resubmitted, this time with a more substantial backing and rationale.

Seek Alternative Evidence

Law, much like a game of strategy, requires adaptability. If one piece of evidence fails to make the mark, it might be wise to pivot and seek alternatives. This doesn’t necessarily mean an entirely new approach but perhaps a different angle.

Alternative documents that reflect the same facts, additional witnesses who can vouch for the same events, or even expert testimonies that can bring a new perspective—these are all avenues worth exploring. For instance, if a specific communication between parties is not accepted due to its informal nature, official correspondences or third-party witnesses present during the discussion might serve as a replacement.


An appeal is the legal world’s safety net, providing an avenue for reconsideration. When foundational evidence is dismissed, and it has a significant bearing on a case’s outcome, the appeal process offers a lifeline.

However, it’s not a step taken lightly. Grounds for appeal must be meticulously established, emphasizing the role of the dismissed evidence and the perceived error in its exclusion. This process involves drafting a detailed written brief to a higher court, outlining the reasons for disagreement with the initial decision.

Opposing parties will have their chance to respond, and in some situations, oral arguments might be scheduled. An appeal is a testament to the belief in the evidence’s strength and its capacity to change the narrative of a case.

How Can a Lawyer Help Me With My Evidence?

Professional legal counsel isn’t just an added advantage—it’s a necessity. Through LegalMatch, you can find an attorney suited to your needs, ensuring your evidence is presented correctly and that your rights are defended.

Legal representation ensures that your case is built on a solid foundation, improving your chances for a favorable outcome. Secure your future and assets — consult a real estate attorney today.


16 people have successfully posted their cases

Find a Lawyer