Dealing With A Fired Employee

Where You Need a Lawyer:

(This may not be the same place you live)

At No Cost! 

 Important Things for Employers to Consider After Firing an Employee

Firing an employee is a significant decision that should be approached with care and caution. Factors to consider include ensuring that the termination decision aligns with company policies, is free from discrimination or retaliation, and is supported by proper documentation.

Company Handbook and Termination

The company handbook, sometimes called an employee handbook or manual, serves as a critical guide for employees and employers. It outlines both parties’ rights, responsibilities, and expectations and provides a roadmap for various employment-related situations, including termination.

  • Policies and Procedures: Handbooks often detail the specific procedures that should be followed when considering the termination of an employee. This can include prerequisites like performance reviews, warning letters, and probationary periods. Following these outlined steps is crucial to ensuring that an employee’s termination is justified and can be defended if challenged.
  • Documentation: The company handbook may emphasize the importance of documenting reasons for termination. This can include a record of performance evaluations, instances of policy violation, written warnings, and any other relevant communications. Proper documentation proves the termination decision was based on valid reasons and wasn’t arbitrary or discriminatory.
  • Grounds for Termination: The handbook will often list acceptable reasons for termination. These can range from performance-related issues, violation of company policies, and insubordination to acts like theft or harassment. The reason for an employee’s termination must align with one of these specified grounds to ensure consistency and fairness.

EEOC and Discrimination in Termination

The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) is a federal agency responsible for enforcing federal laws that make it illegal to discriminate against job applicants and employees. Their mandate covers various aspects of employment, including hiring, firing, promotions, training, wages, and benefits.

  • Protected Characteristics: The EEOC ensures that employees are not discriminated against based on race, color, religion, sex (including pregnancy, gender identity, sexual orientation), national origin, age (40 or older), disability, or genetic information. This means that none of these factors can be a wholly or partly reason for terminating an employee.
  • Retaliation: Beyond direct discrimination, the EEOC also protects employees from retaliation. This means that an employer cannot fire an employee for asserting their rights under the laws enforced by the EEOC, such as filing a complaint or participating in an investigation.
  • Compliance and Training: Employers should regularly train their management and HR teams on these laws to avoid potential conflicts with EEOC regulations. Being proactive in understanding and implementing EEOC guidelines can prevent unintentional discrimination and the legal complications that come with it.

By ensuring that terminations align with the guidelines in the company handbook and do not infringe on the rights protected by the EEOC, employers can minimize the risk of legal challenges and maintain a fair, transparent workplace environment.

What to Do After Firing an Employee

Once an employee has been let go, the company’s human resources department must handle various administrative tasks and communications to facilitate the transition.

Human Resources and the Termination Process

Human Resources (HR) plays a pivotal role in managing the termination of an employee, as they oversee and implement many of the protocols and processes associated with an employee’s exit. Their responsibilities are multifaceted, ensuring not only the legal and ethical execution of termination but also the well-being and rights of the departing employee.

  • Pre-Termination Review: Before the termination decision is finalized, HR typically reviews the circumstances leading to the decision. They ensure that the grounds for termination are valid and aligned with the company handbook and that appropriate steps (e.g., warnings and performance reviews) were taken before the decision.
  • Final Paycheck: HR ensures that the terminated employee receives their final paycheck, including all earned wages up to the termination date. Laws might stipulate when a terminated employee must receive this paycheck. It could be on their last working day, or there might be a window of a few days to weeks.
  • Benefits Administration: The HR department informs the employee about the status of their benefits post-termination. This can include information on health insurance (like COBRA), pension plans, stock options, or any other benefit schemes the employee was a part of.
  • Owed Leave: If the company’s policy or state laws allow employees to be paid for accrued but unused vacation or sick leave, HR ensures this is added to the final paycheck or paid out as required.
  • Company Property: HR coordinates the return of company assets, ranging from laptops, ID badges, and uniforms to company cars. They maintain a checklist to ensure all items are returned and accounted for.
  • Access Revocation: To maintain company security, HR works with IT departments to ensure that the terminated employee’s access to company networks, databases, email, and other digital systems is revoked promptly. This helps safeguard company data and intellectual property.
  • Exit Interview: HR conducts exit interviews with departing employees in some organizations. This can provide insights into workplace dynamics, reasons for the employee’s dissatisfaction, or other feedback that can be valuable for organizational improvement.
  • Documentation and Record Keeping: HR maintains a detailed termination record, including reasons, communications, and other relevant documentation. This becomes crucial if there is a future dispute or legal challenge.

By meticulously handling these aspects of the termination process, HR ensures a smooth transition for both the company and the departing employee and minimizes potential risks and disputes.

Informing Employees Within the Company

Handling communication within the company following a termination is crucial for maintaining morale and clarity.

It’s possible that a situation involving a fired employee contacting current employees might arise to discuss their side of the story or seek support. Companies need to provide guidelines on how to handle such situations. While employees can communicate outside of work, discussing confidential company matters can be restricted.

Providing References for Terminated Employees

Potential employers might request references when a former employee seeks a new job.
HR should have a consistent policy regarding the provision of references. Some companies only confirm dates of employment and job titles, while others might provide more detailed references. Whatever the policy, it should be applied consistently to avoid potential discrimination claims.

Dealing With Legal Proceedings If an Employee is Fired

Terminated employees may challenge their termination or claim rights such as the right to collect unemployment. Being prepared to address these challenges is crucial.

After termination, an employee might file for unemployment benefits. Employers have the right to contest these claims, especially if the employee was fired for misconduct. However, contesting should be based on valid reasons, and employers should be prepared to provide evidence.

If employees feel they were terminated for discriminatory reasons, they might file a complaint with the EEOC. Employers should be prepared to cooperate with the EEOC and provide necessary documentation supporting their decision to terminate.

When Should I Contact an Employment Lawyer?

Terminations can be complex and fraught with legal pitfalls. If you are an employer unsure about the termination process or facing potential legal challenges, consider seeking professional guidance.

If you’re an employer facing these challenges, consider contacting a wrongful termination lawyer through LegalMatch. They can provide insights, review your documentation, and protect you against potential lawsuits.


16 people have successfully posted their cases

Find a Lawyer