Workplace Investigations and Employee Privacy

Where You Need a Lawyer:

(This may not be the same place you live)

At No Cost! 

 What is "Privacy in the Workplace"?

In comparison to an individual’s private life, a person’s legal right to privacy in the workplace is usually much less. The reasonable expectation of privacy correlates to the United States Constitution and the privacy protections afforded in the Fourth Amendment.

In the workplace, the area technically belongs to the employer. As such, desks and offices may be subject to search. Nevertheless, a locked desk drawer or a confidential discussion may receive more privacy protections than spaces deemed more unrestricted. Work computers, email accounts, and phone systems may also be monitored.

An employee’s personal belongings, such as a cell phone, bag, or purse, typically have a higher expectation of privacy. If something was stolen, or if the worker works in a diplomatic or high-risk safety position, the employer may search the worker’s belongings.

If a search is performed for no sound reason, the employer’s actions may be illegal. If you are entangled in a workplace investigation, be sure to review your employee handbook on how investigations are conducted.

Government workers have different due process rights than those in the private sector. If the policy states you have a right to representation, it is usually smart to use it. It is necessary to recognize that human resources and company attorneys are in place to cover the business, not you.

Can My Employer Read My Email?

The activity produced on work computers and systems is considered company property. This includes email. Further, many employers now have email systems that make duplicates of all messages sent and received. This data is kept to study for illegal use, productivity, and any other issues.

It is essential to mention that privacy rules differ by state. What may hold true in one state may not be the norm in another. Additionally, each company’s duty is to have its own guidelines concerning privacy rights. For example, if a business has a rigid procedure that restricts personal use of email and computers, the business would have the freedom to access emails in case of litigation.

Private computers and private email accounts that are accessed carry a reasonable expectation of privacy. Nevertheless, if private data is dispatched on the employer’s network, the employer may have credentials to its contents. The bottom line is if an employee wants to keep a personal matter hidden, they should not use work-related software or hardware concerning such issues.

Can My Employer Hide Cameras at the Office?

Employers are typically permitted to observe their workers through security cameras. However, the cameras usually cannot be in areas deemed intrusive. For example, a camera positioned in a bathroom or dressing area is presumably restricted.

Other sites, such as a cubicle or a break room, may also be deemed a space where an employee would have a reasonable expectation of privacy. If an employer uses cameras, they are instructed to inform workers of their use.

Can My Employer Search My Car or Me?

An employer is usually not permitted to search an employee’s car. However, there are abnormalities. If the car is a work car that the company owns, it is considered the employer’s property and has a right to search. An employee-owned car may be searched if it is parked on the company’s premises, and there is a company guideline declaring that any automobiles on the property are subject to search.

As mentioned previously, some circumstances may permit an employer to search the worker. Thievery and high-risk security zones make personal searches more conceivable.

Can My Employer Listen To and Document My Phone Calls?

An employer may listen to any business-related telephone calls without letting workers know they are listening in. If a personal call comes in, the employer must hang up immediately unless the employee knows the employer is listening and consents to it. Assume the employer has a policy of no personal calls. In that case, employees risk having their personal calls monitored. Since a distinction is not clear-cut, it is best to avoid personal calls at work.

Suppose the employee’s cell phone is one that the company owns. In that case, it is important to remember that the employer may also have access to location data. Employers have the right to record audio, so long as the recordings are not taken in areas where a reasonable expectation of privacy exists, such as a bathroom or changing room.

Does My Employer Have a Right to Ask Questions About My Personal Life?

Employers are typically not permitted to ask questions regarding your personal relationships. Questions about your personal life based on a protected status (such as your race, age, sex, disability, etc.) are forbidden. Workers should not be asked about their spouses, kids, or other relatives. Pregnancy-related inquiries are also not permitted.

Inquiries concerning tobacco, drug, and alcohol use are lawful if the employer asks the worker if they have ever been reprimanded for tobacco or alcohol use while on the job. As for drug use, an employer can ask about illegal drug use because it is not necessary to know about personal prescription drugs.

Can My Employer Test for Drugs and Alcohol?

Yes, it is legal for an employer to test workers for drugs or alcohol. In some states, an employee can only be requested to take a drug test after passing the interview stage, and they have accepted an offer of employment. Employers may conduct random drug screenings, but they cannot single workers out. It must be all or no one.

Suppose there has been an accident and an employer believes drugs or alcohol were involved. They are permitted to perform a drug and alcohol test in that case. Nevertheless, requiring a test without explanation is normally not allowed.

Drug and alcohol testing regulations differ by state. In positions that involve a level of security or safety, such as those held by the U.S. Department of Transportation, drug testing is covered by federal or state requirements.

Can My Employer Monitor What I Do on the Internet?

The employer can monitor internet activity that is performed on a work computer. Suppose the employee owns the computer. In that case, the employer cannot access information stored on that computer without a court order.

However, if information from a personal computer is dispatched through the employer’s network, the employer would likely have access to its contents and data.

What Can I Do If My Employer Violated My Rights in the Workplace?

Suppose your rights have been infringed in the workplace. In that case, you should file a complaint with human resources and contact a local workplace attorney as soon as possible. Employees are afforded many protections at work, and if any of those are violated, the issue must be addressed. An experienced employment attorney in your area will provide guidance and assistance with your case and advise you of your best options.

An attorney on LegalMatch’s lawyer database can help you resolve your case if your rights have been infringed by your employer. Don’t try to face your employer alone. Get the help of an experienced employment attorney through LegalMatch today to get the peace of mind and legal resolution you deserve. There is no fee to schedule an initial consultation.

Law Library Disclaimer


16 people have successfully posted their cases

Find a Lawyer