Pros and Cons of Exempt vs Non-Exempt Employee

Where You Need a Lawyer:

(This may not be the same place you live)

At No Cost! 

 What Is an Exempt Employee?

An exempt employee is “exempt” from overtime pay regulations.

Exempt status has nothing to do with the actual job description or the employee’s title but rather with the employee’s obligations and responsibilities.

Even though the definition varies by location, a worker is typically exempt if they have greater duties than the ordinary employee and undertake management functions.

What Are Exempt Employee Rights?

Exempt employees are not compelled to “punch a clock.”

The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) puts no restrictions on how many hours an employer may force an exempt employee to work.

Again, state laws may vary from the FLSA in their obligations.

As a result, such personnel is excluded from overtime pay since it is thought that they operate independently and have greater choice in the performance of their job. For example, they are most likely exempt if the individual is in charge of recruiting and firing.

Administrative people, executives, highly trained workers, and licensed employees such as physicians and engineers are all automatically recognized as exempt.

Furthermore, even if an employee is not officially identified as exempt, they may qualify for overtime pay exemption based on their regular tasks.

What Is a Non-Exempt Employee?

Overtime pay is required for non-exempt employees. They are sometimes referred to as hourly or salaried workers (although paying a worker a salary doesn’t automatically convert them into a non-exempt employee).

According to federal law, hourly workers must be paid 1.5x their normal rate for any labor completed above 40 hours in a certain time period, typically a week.

As a result, if non-exempt employees work more than 40 hours a week, they are legally entitled to overtime pay.

Finally, the FLSA specifies that workers earning less than $23,600 per year or $455 per week are considered non-exempt.

What Are Some Non-Exempt Employee Benefits?

Non-exempt workers are protected by the FLSA, which requires their employers to pay them a wage that fulfills federal minimum wage criteria. They must also earn overtime compensation if they work more than 40 hours each week.

Example
Let’s pretend Noah works in retail. Noah is a non-exempt employee due to the nature of his job.

As a result, his company must pay him at least the federal minimum wage of $7.25 per hour as of 2023. When Noah works more than 40 hours weekly, he is paid an overtime rate equivalent to one and a half times his regular income.

Noah’s supervisor, on the other hand, is an exempt employee. He earns more money, but his company does not compensate him for working more than 40 hours each week.

What Are the Differences between Exempt and Non-Exempt Employees?

Exempt or non-exempt status refers to whether a worker must be compensated per the FLSA’s overtime compensation criteria.

According to the FLSA, employers must normally pay their employees 1.5 times their regular rate for any labor done beyond a 40-hour work week.

Nevertheless, some workers are “exempt” from these standards, which means they aren’t eligible for overtime compensation even if they work more than 40 hours per week.

State laws also cover exempt and non-exempt personnel, and each state may have its own meaning of these terms and the concept of “overtime.”

Exempt and non-exempt workers, for example, may be defined differently in California than in other states.

What Are the Similarities between Exempt and Non-Exempt Employees?

Listed below are similarities between exempt and non-exempt employees:

  • Unemployment Benefits: Both non-exempt and exempt employees can collect unemployment benefits, but these benefits may vary with each state.
  • Workers’ Benefits and Rights: Non-exempt workers receive more federal protection than exempt workers. However, federal laws that apply to the right to a healthy and safe work environment, the protection provided under the Family and Medical Leave Act, federal child labor laws, and the right to equal employment opportunities remain the same for both classifications.
  • Tax Liability: There is no difference, as all pay is “earned income” and must be reported.

Which Is Better?

The individual’s preferences and lifestyle determine this.

Exempt workers are often paid more since they must remain and fulfill their allocated tasks.

Exempt workers are also given a significant degree of discretion, which is one of the benefits of being an exempt employee.

Exempt personnel, for example, may often spend time on the job taking breaks without penalties.

Exempt personnel, however, must remain and complete their task, regardless of how long it takes. This is one of the disadvantages of being an exempt employee.

On the other hand, many workers prefer non-exempt roles since they get compensated for every hour worked. They are also often just needed to work the number of hours specified.

However, most non-exempt workers are held to tougher standards during break time. Non-exempt personnel is more tightly controlled when it comes to breaks.

What Types of Disputes Arise over Non-Exempt or Exempt Statuses?

Overtime compensation is not authorized to be waived by either employers or workers.

If an employer fails to pay a non-exempt employee’s due overtime compensation, they may face civil action.

In the case of a lawsuit, the employee is normally entitled to back compensation for their extra hours and other damages.

Other employment legal challenges might arise due to incorrectly identifying a person as exempt or non-exempt.

Furlough, for example, is normally only permitted for exempt workers once they work a full week since exempt employees are typically compensated for a full week’s compensation. As a result, they must be furloughed for a week rather than simply one day.

Finally, when dealing with employee benefits like insurance, medical care, vacation, open enrollment eligibility, and other perks, correct exempt/non-exempt categorization is required. Again, depending on the state, these laws may differ.

What Are the Most Common Overtime Wage Violations?

It is vital to highlight that businesses may not refuse to pay non-exempt workers overtime payments.

Again, if an employee works more than 40 hours weekly, approved by the employer, that person is entitled to overtime pay under the FLSA.

However, this does not preclude the employer from taking disciplinary action against the employee for failing to get prior clearance for overtime work or for breaching company policy governing overtime work.

An employer may fire an employee for breaching company policy by working overtime, but the employee must still be paid for the hours worked.

To recover for an employer’s breach of neglecting to pay overtime payments under the Fair Labor Standards Act, an employee must demonstrate the following:

  1. The employee must show that the employer failed to pay them overtime wages as required under the FLSA;
  2. The employee must then prove that they are a nonexempt employee under the FLSA; and
  3. The employee must prove that an employee-employer relationship existed.

Should I Seek Legal Advice?

An experienced employment lawyer may assist you in understanding your rights and duties as an employer. If you are an employee who has been refused overtime compensation, you should seek legal counsel immediately. Maintain documents and accounts of the occurrence at issue.

If you are an employer, be certain that your workers are appropriately classified as exempt or non-exempt. Failure to classify properly might result in legal ramifications for you or your company.

Save Time and Money - Speak With a Lawyer Right Away

  • Buy one 30-minute consultation call or subscribe for unlimited calls
  • Subscription includes access to unlimited consultation calls at a reduced price
  • Receive quick expert feedback or review your DIY legal documents
  • Have peace of mind without a long wait or industry standard retainer
  • Get the right guidance - Schedule a call with a lawyer today!
star-badge.png

16 people have successfully posted their cases

Find a Lawyer