Writing a Complaint or Demand Letter

Where You Need a Lawyer:

(This may not be the same place you live)

At No Cost! 

 What Is a Demand Letter?

A demand letter is a formal, written document sent by one party to another requesting payment or other actions to resolve a dispute. In the context of car accidents, a demand letter is often used by the injured party to request compensation from the party at fault, outlining the reasons for the demand and the evidence supporting the claim, such as police reports.

How to Write an Effective Demand Letter?

To write a strong demand letter, especially after car accidents, you should do the following.

Consult a Lawyer First

Before you take any steps, it’s crucial to consult a lawyer. A professional can guide you through the process, ensuring that your letter is legally sound and maximizes your chances of a favorable outcome. Drafting the letter alongside a lawyer ensures that you’re protected from any potential pitfalls and that your claims are grounded in law.

Start with Personal and Incident Details

This provides a clear context, allowing the recipient to quickly identify the parties involved and the specific incident.

Use a formal letter format. Begin with your name, address, contact details, followed by the recipient’s name and address. Mention the date of the letter and the date of the incident for clarity.

Outline the Incident

A detailed account offers a comprehensive view of the event, reducing ambiguities and providing a clear timeline.

Chronologically detail the events leading to, during, and after the accident. Mention any conversations, actions, or notable details that could influence the claim.

Provide Evidence

Provide evidence to strengthen your claim, offering tangible proof of your assertions and making it more challenging for the recipient to refute them.

Reference specific pieces of evidence in your letter and attach copies. For example, “Attached you’ll find a copy of the police report, dated xx/xx/xxxx.” Keep original documents safe and only send copies.

Specify the Amount

Clearly stating the amount you’re demanding provides a direct call to action, ensuring the recipient knows precisely what is expected.

Itemize the damages – medical bills, repair costs, lost wages, and others. This breakdown should culminate in a total amount demanded. Ensure this amount is realistic, defensible, and covers all current and potential future costs related to the incident.

Set a Deadline

A deadline creates urgency, pushing the recipient to act and preventing indefinite delays.

Be reasonable. Depending on the complexity of the claim, a few weeks might be appropriate. Mention the deadline clearly, for example, “I expect a response by xx/xx/xxxx.”

End Professionally

A professional conclusion reiterates the seriousness of your demand and underscores your readiness to escalate matters if needed.

Close the letter with a statement of intent, like “If I don’t receive a response by the aforementioned date, I’m prepared to pursue legal action to protect my rights.” Finish with a formal closing, such as “Sincerely,” followed by your signature.

Each of these steps is essential in ensuring your demand letter is effective, clear, and legally defensible. Drafting it alongside a legal professional ensures accuracy and amplifies its weight.

What Is the Next Step after the Letter of Demand?

After sending the demand letter, the next step is to await a response. The recipient may agree to your terms, offer a counter-proposal, or deny the claim. It’s essential to be prepared for negotiations. If an agreement is reached, ensure all terms are documented in writing. If no agreement is achieved, you might consider mediation or pursuing a lawsuit.

What Happens If a Demand Letter Is Ignored?

If a demand letter is ignored, the sender has a few options. They can choose to send a follow-up letter, initiate legal proceedings, or seek mediation. Ignoring a demand letter doesn’t absolve the recipient of potential liability; it may, in fact, strengthen the claimant’s position in court.

Send a Follow-up Letter

If the initial demand letter goes unanswered, a follow-up letter serves as a second notice, emphasizing the seriousness of the claim and the sender’s intent to pursue it. This letter can reiterate the details of the claim, provide a brief summary of the initial letter, and stress the importance of addressing the matter promptly.

Sometimes, letters might be overlooked or delayed. A follow-up letter acts as a reminder and shows persistence on the part of the claimant. Additionally, consistent written communication serves as evidence of the claimant’s efforts to resolve the issue without legal action.

Initiate Legal Proceedings

If the recipient continues to ignore the demand, the sender can initiate a lawsuit. This involves filing a complaint or petition in the appropriate court, detailing the claim, the damages, and the relief sought.

Ignoring legitimate claims can sometimes force the claimant’s hand, making legal action the only avenue to redress. Once a lawsuit is initiated, the recipient (now the defendant) will be legally obligated to respond. A failure to do so might lead to a default judgment in favor of the claimant.

Seek Mediation

Mediation involves a neutral third-party (the mediator) who facilitates communication between the two parties, helping them come to a mutually agreeable resolution. Mediation is less formal than court proceedings and is focused on finding a middle ground.

Mediation can be a faster, less adversarial, and cost-effective way to resolve disputes. It’s particularly useful when both parties are open to compromise. Successful mediation can lead to a binding agreement that satisfies both sides.

Ignoring a Demand Letter: Implications and Strategy

While a demand letter is an informal request, ignoring it isn’t advisable. In many jurisdictions, showing persistent efforts to address a grievance amicably can strengthen the claimant’s position if the matter proceeds to court. The court could view the recipient’s lack of response as negligence or bad faith, potentially favoring the claimant in decisions. On the flip side, timely and appropriate responses to demand letters can often prevent costly legal battles, benefiting both parties.

In any case, whether you’re sending a demand letter or have received one, consult with a legal professional to understand the implications and chart the best course of action.

What About Personal Injury Cases?

In personal injury cases resulting from car accidents, the demand letter takes on added significance. It should detail not only the incident but also the extent of the injuries, medical treatments received, ongoing therapies, lost wages, and emotional trauma. Providing evidence, such as medical reports and doctor’s notes, strengthens the claim.

The compensation amount should reflect both current and future medical expenses, potential lost earnings, and non-economic damages like pain and suffering.

Accidents can result in injuries that require immediate treatment as well as prolonged care or rehabilitation. Some injuries might manifest complications or require surgeries later on. The compensation should not only cover the existing medical bills but also anticipated future medical costs. This ensures that the injured party doesn’t have to bear future medical expenses out of their pocket due to an accident caused by another party.

Compensation should cover wages lost during the recovery period. If the injury impairs the person’s ability to work in the future, the compensation should reflect potential lost earnings or reduced earning capacity.

Beyond the tangible costs, injuries can inflict emotional distress, mental anguish, and reduced quality of life. Such damages are intangible but real and can be more debilitating than physical injuries. Factors like the severity of pain, the longevity of suffering, and the impact on daily life are considered when determining compensation for pain and suffering.

In sum, for compensation to be truly just and comprehensive, it must encompass the multifaceted impact of the injury on the victim’s life, both in tangible and intangible ways.

Should I Contact a Lawyer?

Absolutely. An experienced civil lawyer can provide invaluable guidance, ensuring your rights are protected and enhancing the chances of a favorable outcome.

Looking for legal advice? Find the right civil lawyer through LegalMatch today.

Law Library Disclaimer


16 people have successfully posted their cases

Find a Lawyer