What is a Demand Letter?

Where You Need a Lawyer:

(This may not be the same place you live)

At No Cost! 

 What Is a Demand Letter?

A demand letter is a formal communication typically sent by one party to another, seeking voluntary compliance to rectify a dispute. In the context of personal injury cases, such as slip and fall cases, the injured party writes a demand letter to the at-fault party or their insurance company.

The letter communicates the injured party’s claim, detailing the incident, the injuries sustained, any necessary medical treatment, and the financial losses incurred.

What Should Be Contained in a Demand Letter?

A properly-written demand letter can substantially influence the direction of a legal dispute, potentially prompting a resolution without the need for a lawsuit. Here’s what should typically be included.

Clear Identification of the Parties Involved

The demand letter should clearly identify all parties involved. This includes not only the sender (injured party) but also the recipient (at-fault party). It’s essential to list complete names, addresses, phone numbers, and, when applicable, insurance policy numbers.

Example: “This letter is sent by John Doe (Address, Contact Number) to Jane Smith (Address, Contact Number) and her insurance company (Name, Policy Number).”

Why Include This: Precise identification aids in establishing the legitimacy of the claim, ensuring that the letter reaches the correct recipient, and provides a clear reference for future communication.

Details of the Incident

A factual account of the event leading to the slip and fall accident should be included. The narrative should be clear and concise, capturing the time, place, and circumstances of the incident.

Example: “On January 2, 2023, at approximately 8:30 AM, Mr. Doe slipped and fell on an icy pathway leading to the main entrance of Ms. Smith’s residential property located at (address).”

Why Include This: A detailed account paints a vivid picture of the incident, providing a clear basis for the claim.

Evidence of Liability

In this section, outline the reasons why the recipient is at fault. It might be their failure to address known hazards, violation of safety regulations, or negligence in maintaining the property.

Example: “The pathway where the slip and fall occurred was left untreated despite the freezing temperatures. This neglect in basic winter maintenance directly led to the hazardous condition causing Mr. Doe’s accident.”

Why Include This: By attributing fault, you justify the purpose of the demand, tying the recipient’s actions or inactions directly to your injury.

Description of Injuries and Medical Treatment

Detail the specific injuries sustained and the medical treatment required. Attach supporting medical documents like doctor’s reports, hospital bills, and treatment receipts.

Example: “As a result of the fall, Mr. Doe suffered a broken wrist, necessitating immediate medical attention, subsequent physical therapy, and causing him significant pain.”

Why Include This: These details, supported by medical documentation, substantiate your claim by directly linking your injuries and the required treatment to the incident.

List of Damages

Specify all financial losses incurred as a result of the accident. This includes tangible expenses like medical bills, loss of earnings, and property damage, along with non-economic damages like pain and suffering.

Example: “The total medical expenses amounted to $7,500, lost earnings were $2,000 due to missed work, and the non-economic damages for pain and suffering are valued at $5,000.”

Why Include This: Providing a detailed breakdown of your damages justifies the compensation you are seeking and allows the recipient to understand the financial impact the incident had on you.

Demand for Compensation

State the amount you believe adequately covers your damages. This amount should be more than what you actually expect to receive, allowing room for negotiation.

Example: “In light of the above-listed damages, Mr. Doe is seeking compensation in the amount of $20,000.”

Why Include This: By stating a specific demand, you set a starting point for negotiations, expressing your expectation of the claim’s worth.

Deadline for Response

Provide a reasonable deadline for the recipient to respond to your demand. This is typically two weeks to a month from the date of the letter.

Example: “We anticipate your response by August 15, 2023.”

Why Include This: Setting a deadline promotes a sense of urgency, encouraging the recipient to take your claim seriously and respond promptly. It also helps to keep the claim moving forward.

What if a Demand Letter Is Not Followed?

The purpose of a demand letter is to settle a dispute before resorting to court proceedings. However, say the recipient fails to comply with the letter’s demands by either not responding within the set timeline or refusing to pay the demanded compensation. In that case, the next step could be initiating a lawsuit.

Before doing so, it’s advisable to negotiate with the recipient or their insurance company to attempt to reach an agreement. If negotiations fail, legal action may be necessary.

Why Would a Recipient Fail to Comply or Refuse to Pay?

There are several reasons why the recipient of a demand letter might fail to comply or refuse to pay the demanded compensation:

  1. Disagreement on Liability: The recipient might not agree they are at fault for the incident or the resulting injuries.
  2. Questioning the Extent of Damages: They might dispute the extent of your injuries or the necessity and cost of your medical treatment. Similarly, they might challenge the value you’ve placed on non-economic damages like pain and suffering.
  3. Insufficient Evidence: If your demand letter or supporting documentation doesn’t convincingly establish the recipient’s liability or your damages, they might choose not to comply.
  4. Financial Constraints: In some cases, the at-fault party may lack the resources to pay the demanded compensation.

How to Negotiate with the Recipient or Insurance Company?

Negotiations can be a critical part of resolving a personal injury dispute. Here are some steps:

  1. Prepare Your Case: Review your demand letter and all supporting documentation. Be prepared to articulate your case clearly and convincingly.
  2. Understand Their Position: The recipient of your demand letter, often an insurance company, will likely counter your demand with a lower offer. Understand that their goal is to settle the claim for as little as possible.
  3. Stay Firm But Flexible: Be open to negotiation while also standing firm on the validity of your claim. Don’t accept a settlement that you believe undervalues your claim, but understand that you may need to adjust your expectations based on the negotiation process.
  4. Document Everything: Keep detailed records of all communication during the negotiation process. This can be valuable if you need to demonstrate the steps you’ve taken to resolve the dispute amicably.

If Negotiations Fail: Legal Action

If negotiations fail to produce a satisfactory settlement, you may need to initiate a lawsuit. Here are the general steps:

  1. Consult with a Lawyer: If you haven’t already, now is the time to consult with a personal injury lawyer. A lawyer can provide valuable guidance throughout the legal process and represent your interests more effectively than you could on your own.
  2. Filing a Complaint: Your lawyer will prepare a complaint, a legal document that outlines your claim and requests compensation from the court. This complaint is filed with the court and served to the defendant (the recipient of your demand letter).
  3. Discovery Process: This is a phase where each side investigates the other’s legal claims and defenses. It might involve depositions, interrogatories, and document requests.
  4. Trial: If a settlement isn’t reached during the discovery phase, the case will go to trial. Both sides will present their case, and a judge or jury will determine liability and the amount of damages.
  5. Appeal: If the outcome of the trial is unfavorable, there’s usually an opportunity to appeal the decision to a higher court.

A qualified personal injury lawyer can guide you through each step, ensuring your rights are protected and your claim is presented in the best possible light.

Do I Need to Hire a Lawyer for Help With a Demand Letter?

While it’s possible to draft a demand letter on your own, the process can be complex and can significantly benefit from a professional touch. A personal injury lawyer can draft an effective demand letter that accurately represents your claim and maximizes your potential compensation.

Having an attorney assist with your demand letter sends a strong message to the recipient that you are serious about your claim and prepared to pursue legal action if necessary.

If you are considering sending a demand letter following a slip and fall incident, or any personal injury case, you can find a skilled personal injury lawyer through LegalMatch. Our database of highly qualified attorneys ensures that you get the professional help you need. Through LegalMatch, you can find a lawyer who will work diligently to protect your rights and advocate for the compensation you deserve.


16 people have successfully posted their cases

Find a Lawyer