Animals left in vehicles chiefly are exposed to the danger of hyperthermia, or heat stroke. For example, Sergeant Tom Lovejoy of Arizona accidentally left his K-9 dog in the police car in front of his house for 12 hours in 109 degree heat, resulting in the dog’s death.
The crime of leaving animals unattended in a vehicle is often specifically regulated by local ordinances and municipal codes. These rules prohibit leaving animals in cars with inadequate ventilation or extreme temperatures that will adversely affect its health or well being. The punishments can be severe, but significantly lower than the penalties surrounding leaving children unattended in a vehicle.
Determining what counts as an animal may sound like a no-brainer, but statutes will differ on the language. Some statutes only mention cats and dogs, while other statutes are more general. A few statutes only include mammals, so check the statute for exact wording to determine if the law applies.
Police officers are required to take reasonable steps when enforcing the law. In the case of “rescuing” an animal in a vehicle, the officer may be permitted to smash the window of the vehicle. The police may also take custody of the animal in question.
Most state penal codes make it a crime to torture, maim, or mutilate animals. Some state rules specifically prohibit carrying pets in cars in any cruel or inhumane manner that causes suffering. However, cruelty-to-animal state statutes usually address intentional, wicked conduct, and thus do not specifically apply to cases where owners unintentionally cause a pet’s death by leaving it in a hot car. Also, state legislatures and city councils have recognized that animals are transported in vehicles for a variety of reasons, and many are done so in a safe and reasonable manner.
However, there has been an increase in public awareness regarding the dangers of hyperthermia to animals over the last 20 years, and, as a result, owners who forget about their dogs in a hot car are unlikely to be subjected to inordinate punishment. As such, leaving an animal unattended in a vehicle may be a misdemeanor in states and cities which choose to enforce these statutes.
There are a few defenses to the misdemeanor of leaving an animal unattended in a vehicle:
You can sue the police for trespass to chattel, an interference with another person’s property. Although all the elements of trespass to chattel could be met, the difficulties in bringing the suit would be contributory negligence and government immunity.
Contributory negligence is the defense that you caused your own car to be damaged when you left the animal unattended. Government immunity is a doctrine that the government cannot be sued for certain actions because it would needlessly interfere with the government’s ability to function properly.
If you are accused of leaving an animal unattended in a vehicle, you should speak to a criminal defense attorney to learn more about your rights, your defenses and the complicated legal system. If the police damaged your car in an attempt to rescue your animal, you should speak to a personal injury attorney to seek recovery.
Last Modified: 03-28-2018 04:26 AM PDTLaw Library Disclaimer
We've helped more than 4 million clients find the right lawyer – for free. Present your case online in minutes. LegalMatch matches you to pre-screened lawyers in your city or county based on the specifics of your case. Within 24 hours experienced local lawyers review it and evaluate if you have a solid case. If so, attorneys respond with an offer to represent you that includes a full attorney profile with details on their fee structure, background, and ratings by other LegalMatch users so you can decide if they're the right lawyer for you.