Disputes over Property Values

Where You Need a Lawyer:

(This may not be the same place you live)

At No Cost! 

 What Are Property Values?

Property value is the total value of a structure or piece of land at the moment of sale or transfer.

A property’s worth could constantly fluctuate as a result of things like:

  • Use and abuse
  • Growth of neighborhoods and communities
  • Property improvements, repairs, or renovations
  • Local zoning legislation changes

Other variables may also influence property value. For instance, a house that numerous different people have owned throughout the years can be valued differently than one that has never been occupied. Regional costs and markets will also impact property value. The property value will typically not match the final selling price exactly.

Property value and property price or selling price are not the same things. Property value can be thought of as an estimation of the actual value of the house or property. Due to things like negotiation prowess, market needs, and other considerations, selling prices can frequently be either greater or lower than the property value. Property value, therefore, plays a role in a variety of real estate issues.

Concepts of Valuation: A Basic Introduction

Technically speaking, a property’s value is the present value of its potential future benefits. Real estate often has benefits that are realized over a longer period of time than consumer products.

The four components of value—economic, social, governmental rules and regulations, as well as environmental factors—must all be taken into account when estimating a property’s value, along with the following:

  • The desire or requirement for ownership accompanied by the financial means to fulfill that demand
  • The capacity to satiate the requirements and preferences of potential owners
  • Scarcity results from a limited number of competing properties.
  • The simplicity of transferring ownership rights

Value vs. Price

Something’s cost or price does not always determine how valuable it is. Costs include actual outlays for things like labor or materials. Price, on the other hand, refers to the amount paid for something.

Value is not determined by cost or price; nonetheless, they can influence it. Even though a house may be sold for $150,000, its worth may actually be much greater or lower. If a new owner finds a serious issue in the property, like a bad foundation, the value of the house can be lower than the purchase price.

How Do Conflicts Over Property Valuation Occur?

Property value disputes can happen for a number of different reasons. Conflicts regarding property valuation could result from any of the following:

  • Accidental mistakes: Examples include providing the wrong number of bedrooms, giving the building’s size incorrectly or incorrectly, omitting to mention flaws like rust, foundation cracks, or pest damage, and failing to specify the various exemptions.
  • Absolute fraud: A typical fraud plan involves a mortgage or real estate business teaming up with a property appraiser to inflate the home’s worth. To increase their profit on the transaction, both the real estate business and the appraiser may break the law.
  • Ambiguity in the laws: Different laws and methods may apply in some jurisdictions for valuing homes. The laws in the neighborhood where your home is located may be very different from one located five minutes away. In such circumstances, legal counsel may be necessary for research purposes.

Accidental Mistakes

Sometimes disagreements over property values arise from unintentional calculation errors. For instance, it’s possible that whoever conducted the value figured out the square footage erroneously or made some inadvertent error.

Sometimes a specialist in real estate law and property management law is needed to see the problem. An attorney may frequently swiftly resolve these kinds of valuation disputes by locating and fixing unintentional errors.

Examples of Fraud

It is typical for one party to purposefully overstate a property’s worth to benefit themselves financially. You ought to speak with an accomplished lawyer to protect your rights.

A qualified real estate lawyer can uncover fraud, collect damages, and ideally assist you in avoiding it altogether by using valuation specialists and the legal system where necessary.

Conflicting Laws

Some people might find it challenging to comprehend the laws governing property assessment. The worth of the property can vary depending on the circumstances. Property taken by the government through eminent domain may not have the same value as property sold by a private party (when the government takes property for public use).

When two or more parties cannot agree on which laws should be applied to the valuation in a certain circumstance, it can be challenging to reach a value agreement, especially if one party lacks real estate law expertise. An expert real estate lawyer can help you comprehend the relevant valuation rules and ensure that the subject property is fairly appraised.

How Are Real Estate Values Calculated?

A property appraiser must typically be hired in order to determine a property’s value. This person is skilled at determining a home’s worth through a thorough evaluation of the property. In order to estimate the home’s value, the appraiser will look for things like structural problems, additions to the property, and boundary lines. They will also take nearby properties that are similar into consideration.

In rare cases, both the buyer and the seller might each hire a separate appraiser to help them reach an agreement on the property’s valuation.

What Are a Few Typical Property Value Disputes?

Typical disagreements over property prices include:

  • Not disclosing any flaws or problems with the property that could reduce its value.
  • Unexpected shifts in the commercial environment (such as a recent natural disaster in the area or a sudden increase in local crime rates).
  • Default on a contract (for instance, agreeing to a certain property price, then attempting to change the value at the last minute).
  • Disagreements over the marketability of the title.

Fraud or misrepresentation is thus one of the key things to watch out for in a property valuation dispute. The sales transaction may be impacted if one or more parties give false information about the property’s value or any other feature. Such fraud may also result in other legal repercussions.

How Are Differences in Property Values Handled?

Usually, in the case of a dispute over property valuations, a monetary damages award may be appropriate. This would aid the non-violating party in recouping dispute-related losses.

However, they would need to be able to demonstrate their losses, which might necessitate the production of numerous papers and other proof. Other conflicts can be over changing the property’s boundaries or making changes to the land itself.

There are frequently entire businesses specialized in giving extremely detailed property valuation lists, such as consulting listings.

You can resolve some property value issues by:

  • Adding a second appraiser
  • Getting court involvement (especially for a title dispute)

In some circumstances, a formal lawsuit can be required to resolve a property valuation issue.

This might occur, for example, if one party lost money on a home sale transaction as a result of a breach or if one party would unfairly benefit from the sale.

Should I Consult a Lawyer to Help Me Resolve a Property Values Issue?

Property valuation disagreements are frequently complex and may necessitate legal counsel. If you need assistance settling a property issue, you might need to find a local property lawyer.

To find out what rights and choices you have regarding the property, your attorney can examine the local laws in your area. Additionally, your attorney can represent you in court if you need to file a lawsuit for compensation or other relief.

Law Library Disclaimer


16 people have successfully posted their cases

Find a Lawyer