Why Paternity Matters in Child Support Cases in New York?

Where You Need a Lawyer:

(This may not be the same place you live)

At No Cost! 
Legally Reviewed
Fact-Checked

 Why Is Paternity a Problem in New York Child Support Cases?

Paternity is often the most important and crucial aspect in New York child support cases, as without it, the legal door to financial responsibility will stay shut. When a child is born to unmarried parents, the biological father is not automatically recognized as the legal parent. This means that the presumed biological father has no obligation in paying child support, nor does he have rights to custody or visitation, unless paternity is first formally established.

In order to formally establish paternity, the state requires either an “Acknowledgement of Paternity” to be signed by both parents or a court issued “Order of Filiation” that legally identifies the father, as outlined in Family Court Act Section 542.

The main problem with paternity arises when paternity is disputed or unclear. A mother may seek child support, but without legal proof of fatherhood, the court cannot enforce any payment. Conversely, a man may be wrongly identified as the father and face financial obligations for a child who isn’t biologically theirs.

Paternity DNA testing is often utilized by the courts to resolve these disputes, but the process can be emotionally charged and legally complex. Until paternity is confirmed, any child support case remains in limbo, delaying support and straining relationships.

Complicating matters even further, timing and legal procedures are critical. A paternity petition must be properly filed, served, and heard in Family Court. Parties may also need to navigate multiple hearings before an order is issued.

It is important to note that if the child receives public assistance, the Department of Social Services may even be the party that initiates the petition, adding another layer of bureaucracy in the child support case. In short, paternity is not just a biological question, it’s a legal gatekeeper that determines whether child support can be pursued at all.

If you are facing issues regarding paternity, whether you are the mother or father, then it is recommended to immediately set up a legal consultation in New York with New York lawyers who are experienced in handling paternity matters. As can be seen, paternity importance in child support cases is crucial and these attorneys will be able to guide you in resolving such issues.

Basics of Establishing Legal Paternity in New York

Establishing legal paternity in New York is the gateway to securing a father’s rights and responsibilities, as without it, there is no legal tie between father and child. It is also the gateway for the mother being able to pursue child support.

If the parents are married at the time of birth, then paternity is presumed. Otherwise, it must be formally established either voluntarily or through court proceedings. This legal recognition allows the father to seek custody, visitation, and ensures the child can receive financial support, inheritance rights, and access to medical history.

The process of paternity must be handled with care in order to avoid future complications. The following is a list of general steps to establish legal paternity in New York:

  • Sign an Acknowledgment of Paternity form (this usually occurs at the hospital after birth)
  • Ensure both parents sign and have the form properly witnessed
  • File the form with the appropriate state agency (usually the Department of Health)
  • If paternity is disputed, file a Paternity Petition in Family Court
  • Attend court hearings and comply with any ordered DNA testing
  • Receive an Order of Filiation from the court if paternity is confirmed
  • Update the child’s birth certificate to reflect the legal father’s name

In New York, What Is Acknowledged Paternity?

Once again, in New York, acknowledged paternity refers to a voluntary legal process by which an unmarried man formally accepts that he is the biological father of a child. This is done by signing an Acknowledgment of Paternity form, which is typically done at the hospital shortly after the child’s birth.

Once signed by both parents and properly filed, the document carries the same legal weight as a court order and establishes the man as the child’s legal father. This means he assumes both rights, such as custody and visitation, and parental responsibilities, including child support.

However, this acknowledgment is only valid if the mother was not married at any point during the pregnancy. If she was, then the presumption of paternity applies to her spouse, and the acknowledgment form cannot be used.

It is important to note that signing the form waives the father’s right to a court hearing on the issue of paternity, so it should only be completed when both parties are absolutely certain of the biological relationship. Once filed, the father’s name can also be added to the birth certificate, and the child gains access to specific benefits like inheritance and medical history.

What Is Presumed Fatherhood in New York?

Presumed fatherhood in New York applies when a child is born to a married couple. In such cases, state law automatically assumes the husband is the child’s legal father, regardless of any biological ties.

This presumption grants the father full parental rights and responsibilities without needing to establish paternity through court or acknowledgment. If the mother was married at the time of conception or birth, this legal presumption stands unless challenged and overturned by a court.

What Is Alleged Fatherhood in New York?

Alleged fatherhood in New York refers to a situation where a man is claimed to be the biological father of a child, but they have not yet been legally recognized as such. This can happen when either the mother, the man himself, or another party asserts that he may be the father. Until paternity is legally established, either through a signed acknowledgment or a court order, the alleged father has no legal rights or responsibilities regarding the child.

What if I Have Been Supplying Child Support in New York, but a DNA Test Proves I Am Not the Father?

In New York, if you have been paying child support but later discover through DNA testing that you’re not the biological father, then your financial obligation may still stand. This is especially true if you previously accepted paternity by signing an acknowledgment or were declared the legal father by a court.

Challenging that status is not a simple process. It usually requires proving that your original agreement was based on fraud, coercion, or a major misunderstanding. Even if the court allows you to revoke paternity, you might not be refunded for past support payments. The legal system prioritizes the child’s stability, so undoing paternity is a serious and an often difficult process.

What Happens if My Partner in New York Has a Child That Isn’t Mine?

If your partner in New York has a child who isn’t biologically yours, you generally have no automatic legal rights or responsibilities, unless you’ve legally adopted the child, signed an acknowledgment of paternity, or you were married at the time of the child’s birth.

If you’ve played a consistent parental role, then you may be able to petition for custody or visitation by proving a strong, established bond with the child. Courts will then consider the child’s best interests, especially in cases where you’ve acted as a parent over time. You may also have to take DNA testing to prove that you are not the child’s father.

Do I Have To Go to Court in New York if a Person Claims I’m the Father but I Disagree?

Yes, if someone claims that you are the father and you disagree, then you may need to appear in Family Court in New York. The court can then order a DNA test to determine biological paternity. If you refuse to participate or ignore the summons, it is important to note that the judge may still issue a ruling without your input. This could include legal responsibilities like child support. As such, responding to the claim is important to protect your rights.

Do I Need To Hire a Lawyer To Assist With Matters Involving Paternity?

If you are having issues regarding paternity and child support, then it is recommended to immediately meet with an experienced New York paternity lawyer. LegalMatch can assist you in locating an attorney near you who handles such cases.

As can be seen, the laws concerning paternity in New York can often be complicated, and navigating such issues is often emotionally charged for all of the parties involved. Further, once paternity is established, there are numerous parental rights and legal obligations that will happen, including establishing child support.

An experienced attorney will be able to evaluate your case and help you determine your best course of legal action. They will also be able to help you follow the proper procedure in obtaining or contesting parentage, as well as represent you at any necessary in-court proceeding.

Save Time and Money - Speak With a Lawyer Right Away

  • Buy one 30-minute consultation call or subscribe for unlimited calls
  • Subscription includes access to unlimited consultation calls at a reduced price
  • Receive quick expert feedback or review your DIY legal documents
  • Have peace of mind without a long wait or industry standard retainer
  • Get the right guidance - Schedule a call with a lawyer today!
star-badge.png

16 people have successfully posted their cases

Find a Lawyer