Understanding an Upside Down Mortgage

Where You Need a Lawyer:

(This may not be the same place you live)

At No Cost! 

 What Is an "Upside Down Mortgage"?

An “Upside Down Mortgage” occurs when a homeowner owes more on their mortgage than the current market value of their home. This situation is also commonly referred to as being “underwater” or having “negative equity” in the home. It means that if the homeowner were to sell their home, the sale would not generate enough money to pay off the remaining balance owed to the lender of the mortgage.

Being upside down on a mortgage can occur due to a variety of market factors and can pose a significant financial challenge regarding home purchases and sales.

Can You Sell Your House When Your Mortgage Is Upside Down?

Selling a house with an upside down mortgage, where the debt owed to the lender of the mortgage exceeds the home’s value, is indeed possible, but it requires careful navigation through a complex set of financial and legal considerations. The crux of the challenge lies in the fact that the proceeds from the sale won’t be enough to pay off the existing mortgage, creating a deficit that needs to be addressed.

One of the primary strategies to handle this situation is through a short sale. A short sale occurs when the mortgage lender agrees to accept the sale proceeds as full settlement of the mortgage, even though these proceeds are less than the amount owed. This arrangement allows the homeowner to sell the property at its current market value, a figure that, unfortunately, falls short of their mortgage balance.

For the lender, agreeing to a short sale is often seen as a more favorable option compared to foreclosure, which can be a lengthy and costly process. However, it’s important to understand that lenders are under no obligation to agree to a short sale, and their decision will largely depend on the homeowner’s financial situation and the housing market conditions. In some cases, lenders might consider a short sale if they believe it will result in a smaller financial loss compared to foreclosure.

For the homeowner, a short sale can offer a viable path out of an upside down mortgage, but it’s not without its consequences. One significant impact is on the homeowner’s credit score. A short sale can lead to a substantial drop in credit score, although it’s generally less damaging than a foreclosure. The extent of the impact varies depending on the individual’s overall credit history.

Also, the process of a short sale can be lengthy and complicated. It involves finding a buyer willing to purchase the property at its current market value and extensive negotiations with the lender. These negotiations determine the terms under which the lender agrees to release the mortgage lien on the property.

In addition, there can be tax implications for the homeowner. The difference between the mortgage amount and the sale price in a short sale can sometimes be considered as forgiven debt, which might be taxable as income.

Given these issues, homeowners considering a short sale due to an upside down mortgage should seek professional advice. Consulting with a real estate attorney or a financial advisor can provide guidance on the process. These professionals can assist in negotiating with the lender, understanding the legal and tax implications, and making informed decisions that align with the homeowner’s financial and personal circumstances.

What Causes an Upside Down Mortgage?

An upside down mortgage can arise from a convergence of several factors, often outside the homeowner’s control.

One of the contributors to an upside down mortgage is a downturn in the housing market. When the market experiences a decline, home values can drop rapidly. This decline can be due to several economic factors, including rising interest rates, increased housing supply without corresponding demand, or broader economic downturns that affect consumer confidence and spending power.

For homeowners who purchased their properties when the market was at its peak, this decline can result in their home’s value plummeting below the amount they initially paid, leaving them with negative equity.

Another factor that frequently leads to an upside down mortgage is the initial loan-to-value ratio at the time of purchasing the home. A high loan-to-value ratio means that the homeowner has financed a significant portion of the home’s purchase price through a mortgage. This can be particularly problematic if the homeowner makes a small down payment, as it increases the amount borrowed and, consequently, the mortgage balance.

If the property’s value decreases, the homeowner may find themselves with a loan balance that exceeds the property’s worth.

The terms of the mortgage itself can also play a role in leading homeowners into an upside down situation. Adjustable-rate mortgages (ARMs), for example, can start with a low interest rate that increases over time.

While initially attractive due to lower initial payments, these mortgages can become problematic if interest rates rise significantly, leading to higher monthly payments and slowing the pace at which the principal balance is reduced. This situation can be exacerbated if property values decline simultaneously, a combination that can quickly result in the homeowner owing more than the home’s value.

In some cases, homeowners might refinance their mortgage, potentially increasing the loan amount to cash out equity for other expenses. If this is done without a corresponding increase in property value, it can lead to higher mortgage balances. When coupled with a market downturn, such refinancing decisions can quickly lead to an upside down mortgage.

Local factors can also contribute to a property’s devaluation, leading to negative equity. These can include changes in the neighborhood, such as the closure of major employers, shifts in demographic trends, or increased crime rates, all of which can diminish the desirability and value of homes in the area.

What Should I Do If I Have an Upside Down Mortgage?

If you find yourself with an upside down mortgage, there are several strategies you can consider. Firstly, if you can afford to continue making payments and don’t need to move, staying in the home and waiting for the market to improve might be a viable option. Over time, your mortgage balance may decrease, and home values may increase, restoring equity.

Alternatively, you can explore the possibility of a loan modification with your lender, which may include adjusting the terms of your mortgage to make it more affordable or in line with the home’s current value.

Can the Government Help with an Upside Down Mortgage?

Government assistance for homeowners struggling with an upside down mortgage can be a lifeline, helping to stabilize their financial situation and avoid foreclosure. Several government programs have been designed to address the challenges faced by homeowners whose mortgage balances exceed their property’s current value.

One notable program is the Home Affordable Refinance Program (HARP), which was specifically created to help homeowners in this situation. HARP allows those with little to no equity in their homes to refinance their mortgages, often resulting in lower monthly payments or better loan terms. This can be particularly helpful for homeowners with upside down mortgages as it can provide some relief from high payments.

Another initiative is the Home Affordable Modification Program (HAMP), which focuses on modifying existing mortgages to make them more affordable. This program works by adjusting the terms of the mortgage, such as the interest rate, loan duration, and even principal balance in some cases. These modifications aim to reduce the monthly mortgage payment to a level that the homeowner can manage.

Additionally, some states have implemented their own programs to assist homeowners with upside down mortgages. These programs vary but may include options like principal reduction, temporary payment assistance, or counseling services to help homeowners navigate their financial challenges and explore their options.

Eligibility for these government programs often hinges on specific criteria, such as the date the mortgage was obtained, the current loan-to-value ratio, and the homeowner’s overall financial situation. In some cases, only mortgages backed by certain government entities like Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac may be eligible.

While these programs can provide much-needed support, they are not permanent fixtures and are subject to change. Homeowners should actively research and inquire about the availability and requirements of these programs to determine their suitability and viability for their particular circumstances.

Do I Need an Attorney for Help with Upside Down Mortgage Issues?

Consulting with a mortgage attorney can be highly beneficial. A knowledgeable attorney can provide advice on your legal options, such as negotiating a short sale or loan modification, and can represent your interests in discussions with your lender. Additionally, if you are facing foreclosure, an attorney can guide you through the legal process and may be able to help you find alternatives.

If you are dealing with an upside down mortgage and need legal assistance, using LegalMatch to find a qualified mortgage attorney is a practical step. LegalMatch offers a convenient way to connect with experienced attorneys in your area who can provide the guidance and representation you need.

Facing mortgage challenges can be stressful, but with the right legal support, you can navigate these issues more effectively. Remember, seeking professional legal advice early can help you make informed decisions and protect your financial future.

Save Time and Money - Speak With a Lawyer Right Away

  • Buy one 30-minute consultation call or subscribe for unlimited calls
  • Subscription includes access to unlimited consultation calls at a reduced price
  • Receive quick expert feedback or review your DIY legal documents
  • Have peace of mind without a long wait or industry standard retainer
  • Get the right guidance - Schedule a call with a lawyer today!

16 people have successfully posted their cases

Find a Lawyer