Yes, guardianship can be reversed in New York under certain circumstances. This includes a permanent guardianship. The process of reversing a guardianship is governed primarily by Article 81 of the Mental Hygiene Law (“MHL”) for adult guardianships.
Under such cases, a guardianship may be terminated if the person under guardianship, known as the Incapacitated Person (“IP”) or Person in Need of a Guardian (“PING”), regains their capacity.
Other grounds for termination of guardianship include if the guardianship is no longer necessary due to changes in their condition or support system. The court may also end the guardianship if the IP passes away or if the guardian resigns or is removed for cause.
In order to initiate the reversal process, a Petition for Termination must be filed with the court that originally appointed the guardian. This is outlined in Mental Hygiene Law Section 81.36, which allows the IP, the guardian, or any interested party to request termination. The petitioner must provide evidence, such as medical evaluations or affidavits from caretakers who demonstrate that the guardianship is no longer needed. The court may also appoint a court evaluator or attorney to assess the situation and will hold a hearing before making a final decision.
If the court finds that the IP has regained the ability to manage their personal or financial affairs, or if the original reasons for guardianship no longer apply, then the court may issue an Order of Termination. Once the guardian submits a final accounting and the court approves it, the guardianship will officially end and the individual will regain their full legal rights.
What Is a Guardianship Agreement?
In New York, a guardianship agreement refers to a legal arrangement in which a court appoints a person, known as the guardian, to make decisions on behalf of another individual, known as the ward.
A ward is an individual who is unable to manage their personal, medical, or financial affairs. This can apply to minors, incapacitated adults, or individuals with developmental disabilities, depending on the circumstances.
There are several different types of guardianship in New York, each of which are governed by different statutes:
- Article 81 of the Mental Hygiene Law applies to adults who are found by the court to be incapacitated
- This type of guardianship is tailored to the specific needs of the individual and may cover personal needs, property management, or both
- Article 17-A of the Surrogate’s Court Procedure Act (“SCPA”) governs guardianship for individuals with intellectual or developmental disabilities
- This form of guardianship is more comprehensive and grants broader authority to the guardian
- For minors, the voluntary guardianship of a child is typically handled under the Family Court Act or SCPA Article 17, depending on the court and the nature of the guardianship being sought
It is important to note that a guardianship agreement is not simply a private contract. This means that it requires court approval and judicial oversight. Once a guardianship is granted, the court will issue an Order and Judgment outlining the guardian’s powers and responsibilities. Additionally, guardians are often required to file reports and may need to complete training or obtain a bond if they are managing the ward’s estate.
How Does the Court Decide Whether or Not To Reverse a Guardianship Agreement?
In New York, the court will decide whether or not to reverse a guardianship or grant a revocation of guardianship based on the best interests of the person under guardianship and whether the original reasons for the guardianship still apply.
For adult guardianships established under Article 81 of the Mental Hygiene Law, the court may terminate the arrangement if the individual has regained the capacity to manage their personal or financial affairs.
This is governed by MHL Section 81.36, which allows the incapacitated person, the guardian, or any interested party to petition for termination. The court will consider all medical evidence, testimony, as well as the IP’s current condition and support system before making a decision.
For minor guardianships, which are typically governed by Surrogate’s Court Procedure Act Article 17, the court may reverse or issue an order terminating guardianship of a minor if it finds that doing so is in the child’s best interest. This often occurs when a parent seeks to regain custody or when the child reaches the age of majority (i.e., the age of 18). The court may also remove a guardian for misconduct, neglect, or failure to act in the child’s best interest or welfare.
In both adult and minor cases, the court will usually hold a hearing, review all supporting documentation and evidence, such as medical evaluations or witness affidavits, and may appoint a court evaluator or attorney to represent the ward’s interests. If the court finds sufficient grounds, it will issue an Order of Termination, officially ending the guardianship and restoring the individual’s legal rights.
Find My Lawyer Now!
How Can I Get My Child Back From Guardianship?
In New York, a parent can ask the court to end a guardianship and regain custody of their child by showing that circumstances since the initial order was granted have changed and that it’s now in the child’s best interest to return home. The reversal process also depends on how the guardianship was established, whether it was through Family Court or Surrogate’s Court, and whether it was voluntary or court-ordered.
If the guardianship was granted through Surrogate’s Court Procedure Act Article 17, the parent can file a petition to terminate the guardianship. The court will then consider whether the parent is now fit to care for the child and whether ending the guardianship would benefit the child. The judge may look at factors like the parent’s housing, employment, and their ability to meet the child’s needs.
For guardianships involving children with developmental disabilities under SCPA Article 17-A, or if the child was placed in foster care, the process may involve additional steps. In foster care cases, Social Services Law Section 384-b(7) outlines how a parent can work toward reunification, often by completing a service plan that addresses the issues that led to the guardianship being granted in the first place.
What Are the Steps To Reverse a Guardianship Agreement?
Reversing a guardianship in New York involves going back to the same court that originally appointed the guardian and asking for the arrangement to end. As mentioned above, reversals can happen if the person under guardianship, whether an adult or a child, no longer needs help managing their personal or financial affairs.
The reversal process is guided by Article 81 of the Mental Hygiene Law for adults and Article 17 or 17-A of the Surrogate’s Court Procedure Act for minors or individuals with developmental disabilities.
The first step in reversing the guardianship is to file a petition to terminate the guardianship. This is a formal request explaining why guardianship is no longer necessary. The person under guardianship, the guardian, or any concerned party can file this petition. The person who files for termination will need to include evidence, such as medical records or proof of improved living conditions, to show that the person can now manage their care and finances.
Next, the court will notify all interested parties, such as family members, the current guardian, and possibly a court evaluator or attorney for the person under guardianship. A hearing will then be scheduled where the judge will review the evidence and listen to testimony.
If the judge agrees that the guardianship is no longer needed, they will issue an Order of Termination. Once the order is granted, the guardian must submit a final report and return any remaining property or funds. After the court approves the final accounting, the guardianship will officially end and the individual will regain their full legal rights.
How Long Does It Take To Terminate Guardianship?
In short, it depends. The total amount of time that it takes to terminate a guardianship in New York can vary depending on the complexity of the case and the court’s schedule. Once a petition for termination is filed, the process typically involves serving notice to all interested parties, gathering supporting evidence, and attending a court hearing.
In straightforward cases, this process may take a few weeks to several months. However, in contested or complex matters, the process can take a few months to more than a year.
Do I Need a Lawyer To Reverse a Guardianship Agreement?
If you are wanting to reverse a guardianship agreement, then it is recommended for you to consult with an experienced guardianship attorney in New York. LegalMatch can assist you in setting up a legal consultation with a New York lawyer who has handled cases similar to yours.
Although it is not legally required to have an attorney to petition for the termination of a guardianship in New York, having one can be incredibly helpful. As can be seen, the termination process is often complex, as it involves filing a formal petition with the court, submitting supporting documentation, and attending a formal hearing. All of these legal steps can be overwhelming if you’re unfamiliar with court procedures.
Working with an experienced guardianship lawyer can make the process smoother and more effective. They can guide you through the necessary paperwork, ensure all deadlines are met, and even represent you in court, as needed.
