Understanding Grand Theft Auto

Legally Reviewed
Fact-Checked

 What Is Grand Theft Auto, and How Is it Different From Carjacking?

Grand theft auto refers to stealing a vehicle, when the vehicle’s owner is not present, with the intent to keep it permanently. It is a serious auto crime, and as a theft offense that requires criminal intent, a conviction may be punished harshly, possibly with a lengthy prison sentence.

Stealing a person’s vehicle for joyriding purposes would not be considered grand theft auto, as the perpetrator does not intend to take the vehicle permanently. However, stealing a vehicle to then sell any part of it would likely constitute grand theft auto.

The following elements must be present for an individual to be convicted of grand theft auto:

  1. The defendant somehow took or drove the vehicle;
  2. The vehicle was the property of another person or entity;
  3. The legal owner of the vehicle did not consent to the taking by the defendant;
  4. The defendant intended to permanently deprive the owner of their vehicle;
  5. The value of the vehicle meets the threshold for grand theft, as opposed to petit theft, under the law of the state in which the taking happens.

It is important to note that most states include other vehicles in their definition of grand theft auto, not just automobiles. Some common examples of other vehicles include motorcycles, boats, recreational vehicles (RVs), and campers.

The term “grand theft” refers to the theft offense occurring when the stolen property exceeds the state’s limit on the value of a petit theft. Therefore, due to motor vehicles generally having a greater value than other types of possessions, motor vehicle theft is classified in most states as a felony theft offense.

Grand theft auto and carjacking are two separate crimes. Grand theft auto differs from carjacking in that carjacking is a type of robbery involving force or the threat of force. Most commonly, the threat of force used in a carjacking is a firearm. Both involve the theft of a vehicle, but only carjacking involves the use of force to accomplish the theft.

Grand theft auto is carried out without the use of violence, and the vehicle’s actual owner is generally not present. Carjacking utilizes violence or force, with the vehicle’s actual owner likely present. A defendant who commits carjacking can be charged with robbery or aggravated robbery.

What Are the Likely Legal Consequences for Grand Theft Auto?

Process/Steps: The typical process in a grand theft auto case would involve the arrest of a suspect, arraignment, preliminary hearings, and potentially a trial or plea bargain.

After an arrest, the defendant is arraigned and informed of the charges. The defendant then enters their initial plea. Pre-trial hearings may occur to determine if there is sufficient evidence to proceed. The defendant may then enter into plea negotiations or proceed to trial, where the prosecution must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt

Many states consider grand theft auto to be a “wobbler.” A wobbler is a crime that is not definitively a misdemeanor or a felony, but could be charged as either depending on the specifics of the case.

Grand theft auto charges may be considered a felony, but there are unique circumstances that might reduce it to a misdemeanor. Typically, the crime of grand theft auto is charged as either a misdemeanor or a felony, depending on the circumstances and whether the defendant has prior convictions.

The legal penalties for a grand theft auto conviction could include the following:

  • A jail or prison sentence, according to whether the crime is ruled a misdemeanor or a felony;
  • Community service;
  • Payment of large fines, according to whether the crime is ruled a misdemeanor or a felony;
  • Loss or suspension of the defendant’s driver’s license;
  • Probation of over one year;
  • Restitution paid to the victim.

Once again, the severity of the punishment depends on the circumstances of the case, the judgment of the court and sentencing laws and/or guidelines in the state in which the defendant is prosecuted. Additionally, if other crimes were committed in addition to the crime of grand theft auto, they may be added. An example of this would be if the defendant broke into the victim’s garage in order to steal the vehicle, leading to an additional charge of burglary.

Additional Considerations

State Variations: State variations in grand theft auto laws can include differences in the value of the vehicle required to trigger a felony charge as opposed to a misdemeanor charge, as well as variations in sentencing laws and guidelines. Some states may also have specific provisions related to the type of vehicle stolen. Consulting with a criminal defense attorney familiar with the laws in your specific state is recommended.

Evidence/Documents: Evidence presented in a grand theft auto case can include witness testimony, surveillance footage, vehicle ownership records, and any communication related to the vehicle’s possession. The prosecution aims to establish that the defendant took the vehicle without permission and intended to keep it permanently. The defense may present evidence to counter these claims, such as proof of consent or lack of intent.

Risks/Penalties: If a person is convicted of grand theft auto, they would have a criminal record and this could lead to other negative consequences, such as difficulty in obtaining employment, housing, or certain professional licenses. A conviction may also affect an individual’s immigration status if they are not citizens. The specific consequences can vary depending on the jurisdiction and the nature of the conviction.

Costs/Fees: Other potential costs associated with a conviction may include court fees, paying restitution to the victim, and fees related to vehicle impoundment. The specific amounts can vary depending on the state and the facts of the case. It is important to consult with a criminal defense attorney to understand all potential financial implications.

Eligibility: Eligibility for defenses or alternative sentencing related to grand theft auto depends in part on such factors as a defendant’s age, their prior criminal record, and the specific circumstances of the case. All of these and other factors as well may influence the outcome of a criminal prosecution.

Generally, the focus is on whether the prosecution can prove the elements of the crime beyond a reasonable doubt. Consulting with a qualified criminal defense attorney is recommended to assess one’s ability to claim a defense, or defenses, in a specific situation.

Are There Any Legal Defenses for Grand Theft Auto?

The Importance of Hiring a Lawyer: While it is a constitutional right to represent oneself in a criminal case, doing so is generally not recommended, especially if the case is a misdemeanor or felony criminal offense.

Potential drawbacks include the defendant’s lack of legal experience, unfamiliarity with court procedures, and difficulty in objectively assessing the strengths and weaknesses of their case. A criminal defense attorney can provide valuable guidance and representation to navigate the legal process effectively and best protect a defendant’s rights.

Also, a defendant has a constitutional right to being represented by an attorney. If a defendant cannot afford to hire an attorney to represent them, they may inform the court of this. The court would then appoint an attorney at public expense to represent the defendant.

A criminal defense attorney is best suited for determining if there are any available defenses for grand theft auto, based on the specifics of the case at hand. However, no matter the circumstances, the prosecution must prove that the defendant intended to permanently deprive the vehicle’s lawful owner of their property. If they cannot prove that element of the crime, the lack of intent defense may be utilized.

Should the defendant be able to prove that they did not intend to permanently keep the vehicle, but intended to return it, they may face a joyriding charge as opposed to a grand theft auto charge.

Another defense that may be used is consent. If the vehicle’s legal owner provided consent to the defendant to be in possession of the property, whether temporarily or permanently, a grand theft auto conviction is unlikely. Again, any available defenses will likely come down to intent and consent. Other defenses to theft in general may include intoxication, duress, or mistake of fact.

Eligibility: Eligibility for defenses or alternative sentencing related to grand theft auto would depend on such factors as the age of the defendant, prior criminal record, and the specific circumstances of the case. Generally, the focus is on whether the elements of the crime can be proven beyond a reasonable doubt. Again, consulting with a qualified attorney is recommended to assess eligibility in a specific situation.

Timelines: A statute of limitations sets a time limit within which legal proceedings must be initiated. The specific time frame depends on the law of the state or the federal jurisdiction in which the crime was committed as well as the classification of the crime as a misdemeanor or a felony. Once the statute of limitations has expired, charges generally cannot be filed.

Do I Need an Attorney for Grand Theft Auto Charges?

It is important that you consult with a skilled and knowledgeable criminal defense attorney if you are facing grand theft auto charges or other similar issues. The crime of grand theft auto can be difficult to defend against, and an attorney will be best educated in helping you face your charges and assert your best legal defenses.

An experienced attorney can explain your legal rights to you, as well as your state’s specific laws regarding grand theft auto. Finally, they can represent you in court at any necessary hearings.

Save Time and Money - Speak With a Lawyer Right Away

  • Buy one 30-minute consultation call or subscribe for unlimited calls
  • Subscription includes access to unlimited consultation calls at a reduced price
  • Receive quick expert feedback or review your DIY legal documents
  • Have peace of mind without a long wait or industry standard retainer
  • Get the right guidance - Schedule a call with a lawyer today!
Loading...